Why Celebrate Eid Milad Un NAbi s.a.w

[shardmanny]

Re: Why Celebrate Eid Milad Un NAbi s.a.w

@Sa1eem

For instance, if one gives away half of his wealth on charity to please Allah, or spends all his life in giving education to people free hoping to please Allah, or spends all his life teaching people earning skills again to please Allah, or decides that he/she is going to fast on 1st of January every year to please Allah, etc, etc, etc … than that is not Bid’ah even though Allah does not demand that (it is not fard), neither Prophet (SAW) recommended that or used to do that (it is not Sunnah), nor anyone in recorded Islamic history of Prophet (SAW) time has done that. In other words, as long as a deed (any deed) is performed without considering (having neyat of considering) that as Fard or Sunnah, than there is no bi’dah in there

on the whole the above statement is poor

firstly bold has been done with the approval of Allah SWT

and it is these heresay statements that i have a problem with

DO you or Dont you believe the prophet SAW showed us every form of ibadah? you seem to suggest doing something which the prophet SAW didnt his blessed self do is bettered by what these people can come up with. dont forget this is now one of the biggest events of some peoples calendars.

btw i dont claim to be in a position to outright ban or allow milad, what i really take exception to is poking in of other concepts

@Sa1eem

Hmmm … **I only know one person (Shaitan) and his team in entire universe who had reasons to be unhappy the day Prophet (SAW) was born, are still unhappy about that birth, feel unhappy when anyone remembers and celebrate birth of Prophet (SAW), and throughout tries to demean Prophet (SAW) by various ways, and tries that people, especially followers of Prophet (SAW), forget Prophet (SAW) and his birth. Their hate, grudge and jealously towards Prophet (SAW) is so great that they do not even like people visiting Prophet (SAW) last abode in Madina. **

Khawrjees were declared Kharjees because they started judging other Muslims according to their understanding of Islam and declaring them kafirs (doing takfeer).

Actually, if you will read posts, you will find that it is you, not me, who regularly question beliefs of other Muslims and judge them according to your understanding of Islam, and even do not hesitate to consider them non-Muslim. Now, what should I call you, I would not like to say.

labelling people kharjees is your speciality not just on this forum but everywhere

btw calling someone or group as following shaitan is takfeer, it is nambar wan takfeer.