Why Aisha?

[Lajawab]

Re: Why Aisha?

@PyariCgudia

Oh, hey, I’m not saying Aisha (R) was a bad person. I’m saying she had her character flaws also, although she was probably a better muslim than me, or even you Kaleem.

Nonetheless, that doesn’t mean we shoudl not look into it. If someone bothered to write a hadith on her jealousy over Khadija and bothered to record her role in wars after the Prophet’s death, then its worth researching into.

And not everyone believes that Muhammed (SAW) committed no sin. That’s quite debateable, since the Quran itself has an ayah that reprimands the Prophet. Although heck, if that was my only sin, I’d be happy.

Character flaws? Such as?

Remember, Allah :swt: has sent down Ayahs regarding this lady that you claim had character flaws…It’s not everyone who is mentioned in the Quran except the Prophets (May peace be upon them)…