Whos the Biggest Scholars of Quran?i m mention few names
After Sahaba
The list of the scholars r
Imam Bukhari
Imam Malik
Imam Shafi
Imam Tabri
Imam Kabir
**Allama Mashriqi **
Sir Syed
Allama IQbal
Master Din muhammad
Mufti Shafi
Mulana Yousuf Ludhyani
Mufti Shamzai
Ghulam ahmed Pervaiz
Dr zakir nayak
Ahmed Deedaat
Abdul wadood
I hve studied there scolars only mention U hve studied Suni soonaye bataoo per kisi scholar ko mention nahi kijiye ga
Mention Ur Scholar whom u think r the best
**For me **
**Allama Iqbal **
Sir Syed
Master Din Muhammad
Pervaiz
Dr zakir Nayak
Ahmed dedaat
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
They are many for me to list but the best is Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
**
[quote]
Imam Bukhari
[/quote]
**
He was a Muhaddis not a Mufassir.
[quote]
***Imam Malik*
Imam Shafi
**
[/quote]
You missed Imam Abu Hanifa and Imam Ahmed. Also Ibn Kaseer, Imam Razi etc.
**
[quote]
Sir Syed
[/quote]
**
He was a deviant.
**
[quote]
Allama IQbal
[/quote]
**
Had knowledge but he was not a Mufassir of the Quran.
[quote]
*****Mufti Shafi*
Mulana Yousuf Ludhyani
Mufti Shamzai
[/quote]
Agreed.
**
[quote]
Ghulam ahmed Pervaiz
[/quote]
**
He was a kafir.
**
[quote]
Dr zakir nayak
[/quote]
**
He is only good when it comes to comparative religion.
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
He was a Muhaddis not a Mufassir.
You missed Imam Abu Hanifa and Imam Ahmed. Also Ibn Kaseer, Imam Razi etc.
He was a deviant.
Had knowledge but he was not a Mufassir of the Quran.
Agreed.
He was a kafir.
He is only good when it comes to comparative religion.
Ghulam Ahmed Pervaiz is a kafir?why u think tht?hve u read him or u r saying because of most of the people say?He is the man who understand the arabi with gr8 understanding.His tanasif and research is gr8.Hve u read Master Din Muhammad.
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
Not most people but the experts of this field such as scholars. His tasfeer is against the tafseer as it was done by the Sahabas and Pious predecessors. Any interpretation of Quran that contradicts the fundamentals of Islam is baatil. He denied the authority of Hadees which is kufar.
I have not heard of Master Din Muhammed.
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
Read the Tanasiv of Master Din Muhammad Allama Iqbal And Pervaiz than talk me they r master of Arabic Language.U know Bulk of Ullemaz of The world Gave Fatwa Against Pervaiz And sir Syed tht they r Kafir.and they r not Muslims.u know wht did happened All these didnt prove thtWhos muslim and Even then they dinnt give the defination of muslim.Munir Commette Ko bhi Muslim ke defination Pervaiz sahaab se mili parha hai is bare main
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
I dont need to read the Tafseer of Pervez Ahmed and Master Sahib. There are enough authentic tasfeers that I waste my time reading the tasfeer of a kafir. Sir Syed was a kafir becuase he deined the existenfe of angels, hell, heaven etc. He was a naturalist. Maybe if you read his books, you will know more.
Btw are you pervezi?
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
I m not Pervaizi i m simple muslim Jis ke zindagaye Maqsad sirf Quran per Concentrate Karna hai jis ke liye Main Arabi sikhta hoo.Aur mere nazdik Quran ke Tafsir sirf Quran se hoo sakty hai jis main Arabi sikhna lazmi hai.IS k lie App ko Quranic mafoom parhna hoo ga.Quran ke kuch mislain Tamsilan ayee hai.Is kuch Mahvray(idioms)hai.Is ko samjhnay ke liye Arabi mobeen sikhna hooty hai
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
L0L at simple Muslim, even Qadyanis call themselves simple Muslisms. I see how you have tried to ignore my question. And yea I can see where you are going, after you learn some Arabic, you will claim in to be Mufassir just like your idols Sir Syed and Pervez.
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
Have you ever heard of Akhtar Sherazi, he is a disciple of Ghulam Ahmed Pervez? I have had a personal encounter with him.
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
I dont the Disciples of Pervaiz sahaab i hvent read the tasanif of their students but Pervaiz And Master din Muhammad r gr8 scholars of quran they spend more than 50 years to study the Quran and Arabi
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
[quote]
*Allama Mashriqi *
**Sir Syed
**
[/quote]
**
***Both were deviant, naturalist.
*
[quote]
***Allama IQbal*
**
[/quote]
Not a mufassir, deviated at itmes but had good habit of consulting with ulema so corrected himselves on various aqaidh.
****quote]Master Din muhammad
[/quote]
Never heared of him.
**
[quote]
Ghulam ahmed Pervaiz
[/quote]
**
munkar e hadith
[quote]
***Dr zakir nayak*
Ahmed Deedaat
**
[/quote]
**
***Not muffasirs, however have good knowledge on christianity and other religions.*
**
[quote]
Abdul wadood
[/quote]
**
Ye kon hay???
You have missed many important names.
Moulana Ahmed ali lahori for example was one of biggest muffasirs of recent times.
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
Both were deviant, naturalist.
Not a mufassir, deviated at itmes but had good habit of consulting with ulema so corrected himselves on various aqaidh. ****quote]Master Din muhammad
Never heared of him.
U can say tht Pervaiz is Munkir Hadees wht do u say about those ullema who reject qurani ayaat?Rnt they kafir?Pervaiz Always on the Path Allah has Revealed on Muhammad tht was QUran.Wahi Muhammad(pbuh) ke Asli Taleem.Insaniyaaat ke rahnomi.I know he is munkir Hadees But cant say tht he is munkar e Quran.The Biggest scholar of Quran in recent time.Munkir Hadees hoona bara Jurm hai yea Munkir e quran.Quran to Os hi shakaal main hai jo Muhammad(pbuh)nay logo dia tha.jis main changing na hoye.Hadees tu sab ke pass hai phir yea Ikhtilaf kion.YEa elim o burhan ke batin hai Ghoor o fikar say samjh main aty hai bhai
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
So atleast it is agreed that parvez was munkar e hadith-
Do you agree that rejecting ahadith on the basis of ignorance when ulema always emdorsed a specific hadith is a big sin.?
What others do not not justify what parvez did, khallas
NEXT---->
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
[quote=bao bihari]
So atleast it is agreed that parvez was munkar e hadith-
Tell me Any ullema Who hve knowledge and understanding of Quran?who dont Reject Hadees?Or Do u ask them all hadees in Saha Sita R corrent?He Reject thos Hadees who r against The Taleem of Quran?Ahle Hadees Accept all hadees see them wht he do.Bacharay Ajnabi pooday(Tassavoof)ko islam ke miraj qaraar daity hai Rooz in ke hi waja se Ek naya Firqa Paida hoota hai.
Firqay ke Buniyaad kia hai Ghair Allah ke Kitab aur Woh Kitabain Jo Muhammad(pbuh)ko diye hi nahi thin.Woh in ke Taleem Nahi Thin Woh Muhammad(pbuh)ke Taraf Mansoob kar dain.Muhammad Se pahlay Bhi HAzaroo Rasool Gaye thi Wahaan Yahodi Bhi Thai Essai bhi Thai.Lakin Hazoor nay In ko Bhi Islam ke Dawaat kia In ke pass Woh books nahi thi Jo hazrat e Anbiya per Nazil Hoye thi.Bhai Woh books thin in ke pass lakin in Main tarmeem hoo gaye thi.Insaan ke Joziyaat agaye thi.Is liye on sab ko mansookh kar dia.Abb quran ke Hifazaat Allah kar raha hai.Bolo is kainaat ko nashoonoma daina wala koun hai Ek Allah.Os ke hidayaat Ek hi Kitaab main Mahfooz hai Woh hai quran.Muhammad(pbuh)ke ek Taleem aisi hai jis se kisi insaan ko inkar nahi os ko koi Reject nahi Kar sakta Woh hai Quran.Bhai Quran per Ghoor or fikar kar loo phir in Ghar Allah books ko read kar laina.Pata chaal jaye ga KE on books Agaid Kitnay Qurani hai Aur kitnay islami.Zada tar yahoodi essai aur zartash ke Concept ke Barhmaar nazar ayee gaye.Ayee Quran per Ghoor aur fikar karain aur Firqa bandi Ko jaar se Ukhar phakain kion ke Firqa Bandi aur Mazhabi paishwayaat quran ke rooh se Shirk hai
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
[quote=bao bihari] So atleast it is agreed that parvez was munkar e hadith
Tell me Any ullema Who hve knowledge and understanding of Quran?who dont Reject Hadees?Or Do u ask them all hadees in Saha Sita R corrent?He Reject thos Hadees who r against The Taleem of Quran?Ahle Hadees Accept all hadees see them wht he do.Bacharay Ajnabi pooday(Tassavoof)ko islam ke miraj qaraar daity hai Rooz in ke hi waja se Ek naya Firqa Paida hoota hai.
Stopped reading here.
Ahle e Hadith consider tasawuf as a fitnah-(how wrong are they is another issue. ) do not make ignorant remarks. :)
Wasalam
(Hopefully my last post in this thread)
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
Your Quran posts always reeked of "PERVAIZI" or AHMEDI approach.
I have called you out on that many times before Like Khanbaba has done now.
Pervaiz is not a muslim because he denies the Sunnah. This is the accepted belief of Ahl Sunnah wal Jammah.
You also reject the sunnah. Your many posts before this one say that.
(After some one goes through your mind-numbing roman-urdu posts they will see that.)
Now you are going to jump and say that you don't or start typing in roman urdu.
Go fish some where else...there are no takers of your doctrine on this forum...
Your cover has been lifted. You are completely exposed.
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
Well this so called group of Arabic scholars is hocus pocus. Me and my friend had a personal encounter with one of his own Akhtar Sherazi (he wrote "Religious prostitution", I would advise you to stay awya from it), it took us 5 minutes to make him pack his things and leave.
Just as his likes boast about knowing arabic, he was also talking the same stuff and telling us that so and so verses are translated wrong and this is how it should be, making claims about Arabic. All we had him do was write down the translation of some verses in Urdu as he was claiming, afterwards we asked him to translate those back into Arabic. Now if he has such innate command of Arabic he should not make significant faults and it should either exactly or very close to the Quranic arabic. He refused to do so saying some aain baain shaain and left. That was the last we ever heard from him.
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
I am getting worried bro, your talking like that student of ahmad ghamidi sahab.
Re: Whos the Biggest scholars of Quran
Ahel-e-Sunna Wal Jammah has only authority to declare some one a non sunni, how can they declare some one to be non-muslim?