I was faced with a similar choice once and opted for the cool one. Its not necessary my experience be true for everyone but it was pretty obvious I had made a bad choice shortly afterwards.
*Someone once told me the volatile, crazy and head-over-heels type of love only lasts for a little while. What is left after that is what counts...friendship, compatibility, *respect, admiration, etc. You still love the person but in a different way now...its a mature and very strong type of love. **
Even though you might be more attracted to Guy A...go for Guy B...he will respect you.
I like ...I Like! thanks for this PS2 (LOL, I just realized...this is a wicked new GS name for you...like SomegroovyChick is SGC, LOL