Who is a liar - Nawaz or Dr Mubashir Hassan?

[RC_Cola]

Re: Who is a liar - Nawaz or Dr Mubashir Hassan?

@Patriotgames

My reply to your initial post was in reference to the highlighted part, where you stated that no country in the world is divided in two part where one part is 1600km away from the other. This division was due to the fact where muslims were in majority and there were only two choices either to take the eastern wing or leave it. Mr. Jinnah along with other leaders had accepted it.

So don’t you think Mr. Jinnah along with others may have envisioned the consequence of what would happen to a country that is geographically divided like that? Was it wrong or right?

Quaid was asked at one point how would Pakistan manage its eastern wing and he gave the example of Hawaii. Relatively speaking Hawaii has been treated equally by the US govt. which has given all its states full autonomy unlike Pakistan unfortunately.

Based on the fact that there is past precedence where a poor country could manage that kind of distance between it’s two parts with a hostile country in between.

I have not read anywhere Jinnah gave that statement; but if we are to analyze it now; would you compare Hawaii with rest of the states in US with East & West Pakistan ? I might be wrong but it’s apples to oranges kind of comparison. But better comparison could be Alaska - Russia to US. No?

Plus; even if it was; US was lucky to have Statesmen at the initial stages while things would have been different if Jinnah lived at least 10-15 years after the creation of Pakistan.

I still would have answered the same as I did earlier;

Perhaps Jinnah envisioned that he would not die so soon after the creation of Pakistan or he might have misjudged his team’s capability to keep the country bonded together in it’s infancy stage- both did not happen!