Who here is for Internal Punishment of Trio by PCB/Pak Govt?

[Nikema]

Re: Who here is for Internal Punishment of Trio by PCB/Pak Govt?

@ehsan

Big difference between these two cases. That was an internal enquiry and no examples were made of guys except for salim Malik. But did Malik’s ban stop Butt’s satay baazi, the answer is no.

Butt, Asif and Aamir have been banned and a criminal case is hanging on their heads. I think this punishment enough to deter future satay baazi not only by Pakistani players but others as well.

so I do not agree with your suggestion. In wake of what has happened it is more important to put into affect a system where by new players are educated as to the dangers and are told of the punishment they will face, with examples of these three part of the education system.

Banning them alone will not solve the problem, just like Malik’s case did not resolve the issue earlier.

Why are you looking at where the inquiry happened? One shouldnt have to look beyond the crime and regardless of if ICC has announced their punishment, PCB should proceed with their own. Their crime is far bigger for PCB to ignore and only take ICC’c punishment as enough punishment, as someone suggested above that it is important to make an example of these guys as a symbol for developing zero tolerance policy for future.

It is Important to create a system where new players are educated on this, But tell me if a new education course in any PCB academy is going to have more affect on future cricketers or them finding out how much these guys were made to pay for their crimes for their punishment from PCB/Pak govt by taking the player’s assets/properties/bank accounts etc etc? I doubt if another course in PCB academy or any other educational program will match the affect that harsh punishment for trio will have on future cricketers