Owing to his role in the state’s creation, Jinnah was the most popular and influential politician. He played a pivotal role in protecting the rights of minorities,establishing colleges, military institutions and Pakistan’s financial policy.[36]](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_Ali_Jinnah#cite_note-lastyear-35) In his first visit to East Pakistan, under the advice of local party leaders, Jinnah stressed that Urdu alone should be the national language; a policy that was strongly opposed by the Bengali people of East Pakistan (now Bangladesh). This opposition grew after he controversially described Bengali as the language of Hindus.
So you do agree with me that religion cannot hold people from different cultures together?
I disagree with you....try to understand what I said :
** Religion, Cultural resemblance, traditions and geographical bondings play an important role in forming any nation.**
Pakistan is bond between Sind, Balochistan, Punjabies and Paktoons caz of 100s of years of similarity in culture, traditions, geographical interdependence, trades, Blood relations , history and offcourse Religion
Bottom line is ** " Religion alone cannot make you One country"**
Otherwise....Yemen, pakistan, Iran and Nigeria would have one big country!
Sindhis or Punjabis share close to nothing in common in terms of culture or language with Pushtuns, Chitralis or other ethnic groups of Northern Areas. Why are they in the same nation? Just because of a border? If that was a criteria, Afghanistan and Iran would also be a part of Pakistan.
You are contradicting yourself, By your logic you are an Indian, right? so prove it, since actions speak louder then words. Shri Modi has a nice palace just for your kind..
Sindhis or Punjabis share close to nothing in common in terms of culture or language with Pushtuns, Chitralis or other ethnic groups of Northern Areas. Why are they in the same nation? Just because of a border? If that was a criteria, Afghanistan and Iran would also be a part of Pakistan.
We share common culture, we been movin in and out in each other's provinces for centuries..doing businesses...trading inter mingling in form of settlements....intermarriages, blood relationds....everyting from dress to food...etc..
And this has been going on for centuries...so our ancestors made it one country...We Pakistanies are proud of this union.
Your personal opinion cannot break Pakistan.....or change the course of history.
If you don't like Pakistan than go back to India. I know why you don't like Pakistan...Please flit out that Mqm propaganda..i just checked your profile and found out that you are from Karachi where most people are brainwashed by MQM anti Pakistan Propaganda
We share common culture, we been movin in and out in each other's provinces for centuries..doing businesses...trading inter mingling in form of settlements....intermarriages, blood relationds....everyting from dress to food...etc..
And this has been going on for centuries...so our ancestors made it one country...We Pakistanies are proud of this union.
Your personal opinion cannot break Pakistan.....or change the course of history.
Thanks.
In reality, there is a world of difference between someone from south punjab and someone from buner. It's not even debatable and nor is it my personal opinion. It's reality.
In reality, there is a world of difference between someone from south punjab and someone from buner. It's not even debatable and nor is it my personal opinion. It's reality.
There is a world difference between people from south and north of many countries yet they are one country...Do some research please.
All your arguments to prove that Pakistan is not one country.............is result of that propaganda that Altaf bhai does ( creation of Pakistani biggest blunder) is his propaganda and looks like you have bought the ideology from him.
If you don't like Pakistan than go back to India. I know why you don't like Pakistan...Please flit out that Mqm propaganda..i just checked your profile and found out that you are from Karachi where most people are brainwashed by MQM anti Pakistan Propaganda
Pakistan was created largely by leaders from Bengal, Sindh, and present day India so it's always amusing to me how certain other segments have come to hijack what it means to be Pakistani over the years.
Again, right after you move to Tikrit as your user name claims your origins from there.
You make claims and then you beat around the bush, When you say something you must backup with actions unless you are an arm-chair general. If I change my handle to Shri George W. Bush or Shri Obama can I move to the white house?
There is a world difference between people from south and north of many countries yet they are one country...Do some research please.
All your arguments to prove that Pakistan is not one country.............is result of that propaganda that Altaf bhai does ( creation of Pakistani biggest blunder) is his propaganda and looks like you have bought the ideology from him.
Thanks
I think it's you who tried to prove that Bengal should not have been part of Pakistan to begin with due to cultural differences or are you getting confused by your own double speak?
You make claims and then you beat around the bush, When you say something you must backup with actions unless you are an arm-chair general. If I change my handle to Shri George W. Bush or Shri Obama can I move to the white house?
Yup, that's your internet persona, and since I don't know you personally, I can only go by that in answering your ridiculous posts.
I think it's you who tried to prove that Bengal should not have been part of Pakistan to begin with due to cultural differences or are you getting confused by your own double speak?
Bengal was never part of Pakistan's Original Ideology. Please read the Pakistan Resolution of 1930. It never had Bengal as part of it.
After the report, Maulana Fazlul Haq from Bengal, moved the famous Lahore Resolution, better known as the Pakistan Resolution, “…the areas in which the Muslims are numerically in a majority as in the North-Western and Eastern zones of India should be grouped to constitute ‘Independent States’ in which the constituent units shall be autonomous and sovereign.”
Geographically apart, Culturally apart.....Bangalies were a different nation we never was a part of bangladesh.....
Can Pakistan and China be one couuntry? or can we include Yemen in Pakistan? NO.....................Bangla desh was a mistake imposed on us by the British.
I am very happy that Bangalies broke this unnatural alliance...we are different from bengalies and we Pakistanies have no regrets of their getting separated from us....
Its like weeping after 60 yrs..." O why did the English left us? We were once part of the British empore.........stop crying over spilt milk"
Pakistanies are happy that Bengal is not our part now. Bengal was a disease we never wanted!
You are out of sync and have several flaws in your theory.
Culturally how close are Pathans with Punjabis? Or Punjabis with Sindhis? Or Sindhis with Baluchis?
Its not the Bengal that was a disease but people who think its okay to shout "idhar hum udhar tum".
Yet another blunder and flaw. I see Saudi, Iran, Afghanistan were freed by British rule in 1947, is that right?
Its shameful that people sacrificed their lives for a country whose 2nd/3rd generation thinks that they were good for nothing and that their sacrifice was nothing but waste. I feel ashamed and embarrassed when I see Pakistanis of this view.
By this post of yours you have insulted hundreds of thousands of lives lost during transition from Bharat/Hindustan to Pakistan. People who supported creation of Pakistan should not have been allowed to move to the very same country? Great going dude.
