Re: WHATS wrong with a christmas tree?
I didn’t mean to imply that. Of course you can celebrate the Holy Prophet’s birthday, you can observe the day as a day of remembrance, reflect upon the Holy Prophets (pbuh) teachings. But to make it annual festival, calling it an Eid and holding processions that disrupt traffic, that isn’t really what Islam tells us to do. This did not happen during the Prophet’s time nor after him in the caliphate.