Re: What's with this mentality?
^I think that is normal stuff that every person thinks now and then.
What is referred to in this thread by the poster is, I think at least, why women blame themselves for unnormal things.
I think in cases of abuse, it's what they hear and start believing. I know someone who went through similar things. A lot happened to her. In the end she got fed up and started to fight back which isn't much appreciated in her family... She always hears it's only her own fault. While she also made some mistakes, not everything is her fault and she certainly didn't get herself in those situations!
One of the relationships problems, when the male is bad and the female keeps trying is, that the verb that a home is only made with a good woman is very often wrongly applied. It's true, the woman should be good in order to achieve a good home for the family, but it's not just up to her. If she keeps trying and trying, and the male keeps behaving badly, she can't help it.
Yet, even for most divorce cases, the female is often blamed. Even by her own family. My friend goes through this often, contacts with her family are very depressing for her, so she stays away from them as much as she can. They blame her for her divorce, which is right because she left her ex and started her divorce. Everybody talked her into going back in the past and she always left him when she couldn't take it any more. Finally he is remarried nowadays! But they always blame it on her that the marriage was bad, while he was a bad person and also a hypocrite person [he even disallowed her to tell others that they were married, that they were back together again the last time!]. My friends family knows what he's like, yet they blame my friend, they feel she should have waited twenty, thirty years until he 'changes' and is good to her.... Why should she destroy her life like that when Allah has given females the right to divorce bad husbands? sheesh!
Anyway, to this day, they blame her. And that is the case with many females, when people keep putting it in your head, espcially your own lovely father, mother, brothers, cousins, aunties and uncles, that you are to be blamed, you start believing it.
That is the problem in our culture. Thank God it doesn't happen everywhere anymore, but the problem is still there.
Even remember many aunties, friends of parents and real khala, saying things like they had bad husbands too, or some of them said, theirs were still bad, but they stayed, did sabr all those years, it's true, while sabr is more rewarded by Allah, he didn't give females the right to divorce for nothing. Why raise your children in such a negative atmosphere? Why put your children through the bad things the father does? Why let them live in such a state? In the end, your honour in other peoples eyes is not as important as your honour in Allah's eyes and what Allah thinks about you. Let other people bash you, talk bad about you, you don't live with them, you live with your own children. You live in your own home and when you close the door to your home, you leave the vicious talk and lies outside and relax in your own home. If you stay with a bad husband, you will have honour outside your home, but you will always be miserable in your own home, in your private life...