Re: What really happens? Please clear this up once and for all. (To SHIA on this boar
Ur effort to educate yourself is commendable.......and now that u r listening let me tell u a basic point.....inter sect debates do not ever start from the matters of jurisprudence.....and that is simply because laws themselves stand upon beliefs......it is always the beliefs, their understanding and methods of derivation, tht is debated........for example, if John and Alan were two brothers who have a dispute over a property.......John does not agree that Alan has any right over a given property........is there any room for debate between them to argue over who will take which rooms in the house?......do I win a debate with u if I show u that muftis of wahabhi school or Sunni school of al azhar deem it lawful for a woman to breastfeed an adult? And that this act defies basic principles of Islam, logic and morality?.....the answer is obviously a NO......it is a little more complex than that.....
If u want to know Shia aqaid then please go ahead and tell me what exactly r u looking for and I can direct u towards sources.......r u interested want to know kalaam, tafsir, rating, hadith or just an overall summary?......do u want our earliest scholars and compilers or the current living jurists?........and what is ur preferred language?
Re: What really happens? Please clear this up once and for all. (To SHIA on this boar
I need list of sources of classical writers in Arabic, persian and their translations in Urdu/English. Please make a list of most authentic sources of your aqaidh specialy relating to Quran,Imamat,Sunnah,Muta , Taqiyah related issues.
Having said that the sources/references of shia books i cited in this thread , how authentic are they?
MODS: Can you please split this discussion into another thread.
Ur effort to educate yourself is commendable.......and now that u r listening let me tell u a basic point.....inter sect debates hardly ever go to matters of jurisprudence.....because laws themselves stand upon beliefs......so it is the beliefs and their understanding and methods of derivation tht is debated........for example, do I win a debate with u if I show u that muftis of wahabhi school or Sunni school of al azhar deem it lawful for a woman to breastfeed an adult? And that this act defies basic principles of Islam, logic and morality?.....the answer is obviously a NO......it is a little more complex than that.....
If u want to know Shia aqaid then please go ahead and tell me what exactly r u looking for and I can direct u better towards sources.......such as do u want to know kalaam, tafsir, rating, hadith or just an overall summary?......do u want our earliest scholars and compilers or the current jurists?........what is ur preferred language?
Re: What really happens? Please clear this up once and for all. (To SHIA on this boar
I am sorry gang. I am sunni but honestly this thread is a very disrespectful thread towards shia community. There are no foundation and/or grounds on which thread is based, only self created and self propagated rumors that are based on hatred and childishness.
I am locking this thread and no mod should open it without my permission.
We banned the Ahmedi threads topic on GS just because of that. It looks like that its about time that we need to ban Shia/Sunni threads also.
No more "Innocent"/"Out of curiosity" questions are allowed in R&S that are discussing a rumor based derogation. I am going to turn it into a policy soon