what is the definition of Ahl ul Bayt

Umer called Abu Bakr’s caliphate “an evil” and felt that the muslims were protected from its evil because Abu bakr was such an amazing man.

Umer in turn was nominated by Abu Bakr and Umer created a committee of 6 where the tie breaker vote was with the cousin of the favored candidate.

Let’s have a separate discussion on this instead of accusing me of cherry picking.

Btw if Mr. Heart’s ranking is so relevant for you then Charles Darwin (16), Gengis Khan (29) and Adolf Hitler (39) are much better than Umer who is number (52).

Hadrat Ali inherited the seeds of trouble sown at Saqeefa and strengthened during the rule of the first 3.

Please read Quran, Musa made Aaron his deputy and similar things happened that the companions rather listen to Saamri and his golden calf.