What is a sect? [split from 73 sects]

[cricketplaya]

@diwana

When will you come out openly and say why you REALLY wrote the post with following sentences… ( remind you I have no problem with these whatsoever )

“Ya Abu Bakar Madad
Ya Umar Madad
Ya Uthman Madad
Ya Ali Madad”

Just tell ‘openly’ and ‘sincerely’ and not adding if or but.

After I questioned you, you decied to divide shias in to extremists and non extremists… **Even though I never heard of or saw any shia being so extremist that the person tries to convert other.
**
**Shia think themselves like the jews…either you are from the familiy of “ahle Bait” or not.

It is possible but hard to become a shia after birth. I may be quite wron**g.

Still your theory of extremist shia and not extremist shia is down the drain…They all will not have problem with saying Ya Ali Madad.

Do you think those who say “Ya Ali Madad” are extremist shia???

Not a single Sunni however says openly or believes on …Ya Abu Bakar, Ya Umer, Ya Uthman
Shows how bigot and inflammatory you are.

Brother, it’s better if you go study than to accuse me of whatever that comes to your mind. You clearly have no idea what or who a shia is and how many groups they have within their sect.

@Basim Ali

I don’t see what, his being an infallible Imam, has to do with the fact that fair arbitration had to be carried out (which was never done, in the end).

If Ali (ra) was an infallible human being, then why the need for consultation? Surely if he was so-called infallible he would of made his decision on the spot.

Clearly he was not infallible. Alhamdulillah. May Allah curse those who say such insult. Ameen.

btw, diwana now you see who the extremists shia are? They say their 12 imams are infallible, the Ahle Sunnah have declared them non-believers long ago. Stop trying to act politically correcto like a fairy in lala land, come back to reality.