psyah
January 9, 2013, 7:49pm
61
Re: What if…
**BUT Prophets? No … why? It is because a prophet is never required to be obedient to another prophet - A prophet is directly required to report to Allah (SWT) only …
Isa (AS) will be a follower of RasoolAllah (SAW) whilst maintaining his (AS) title of prophethood.**
to whom does this make sense? Isa will be a follower of Muhammad (saw) > i.e. obedient, but at the same time a Prophet is never obedient to a Prophet. What is with Aron (as) and Musa (as). Was Aron (as) not Prophet as well and obedient to Musa (as)?
I do not know to whom you make sense. Feel free to answer.
Ibn Sadqiue, the likes of you have convinced me in my Path. I first thank Allah (swt) and people like you. I choose logic over madness. You should write a Thesis about this in fact crystal clear Verse which says that you will be among the 4 groups, so in the end meaning that you can become a Prophet. I do not know what you and Psyah have done with such a simple verse confirming what Jamaat-e-Ahmadiyya says, that there can be Prophets. This is crystal clear. Don’t need to twist and turn it around.
I do not know to who it makes sense what you have written, there must be many. I pray for you and them. May Allah guide you.
Logo Sunno, The Ummat of Muhammad (saw) can’t have Prophets after him, but the Ummat of Musa (as) saw so many Prophets after him. Logo Sunno, A Prophet is not obedient to a Prophet, but the Israelite Prophet Isa (as) will be a follower of Muhammad (saw) and maintain the Title of Prophethood. Logo Sunno.
I won’t log in for awhile, I’m done here.
Peace Bigboi
No prophet was required to be obedient to another prophet (AS) … And certainly Isa (AS) will be obedient to RasoolAllah (SAW) and never claim to be superior to him (SAW) … Nor bring another Wahi like the Qur’an … You can count on that!