Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
You’re welcome!
I hope you’re familiar with Dr. Zakir Naik and you’d consider his point of view because he’s considered extremely respectful and authentic among Muslims of the entire world. And he’s an authentic medical doctor as well.
Please read this. If you get convinced please mention that in your reply and if this still isn’t enough for you then I will pray to Allah for you.
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
Just because a “medical doctor” makes a statement, that doesn’t make it true. A “authentic medical doctor” will have research and scientific evidence to back up his claims.
Bottom line is that you can not post a single source of actual science that conclusively proves your statement. You have men…Islamic scholars…who have made these statements. But even these men have posted posted any proof for their statements.
This is a perfect example of dealing with something that is a hypothesis versus a scientific proven FACT. There is nothing wrong with backing up your views/arguments with proven FACTS…but before making that claim, please make sure it is actually a FACT rather than a hypothesis.
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
You sound like people who used to refuse what prophet Muhammad (PBUH) used to tell to people of his times.
And a lot of things in modern world have been scientifically proven no one can give you source to all those things but those are known facts.
I don’t know what will make you convinced, I hope a scientist of NASA isn’t it?
Dr. Zakir Naik is one of the most knowledgeable Islamic scholar of current times or even couple of centuries not just an ordinary medical doctor I or you go to and get medicine when sick. His research and analysis is as authentic as of any biggest scientist in the world.
Ahh the irony of trying to justify a religious ruling by using science, while on the other extreme, poo pooing the same science when if clashes with a religious doctrine.
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
Its allowed in Islam. Allah has made it halal and what He has made halal cannot be made haram. Anyways there’s a solution to it as well. If a woman doesn’t want to share her husband she has a right to state it in her nikkah nama. There we go. Everyone’s happy. And do dua that you have a happy monogamous marriage. Only dua can change destiny. And Allah knows best.
His statement is not ‘research and analysis’ though. In order for his statement to hold any value, other doctors and researchers must be able to back his statement. Did he publish an article in a medical journal making these claims? Does he have a study that proves this? With participants and a control etc etc. Like a proper experiment. All scientific claims in the world have evidence to back it. And that evidence is thoroughly analysed and those theories tested in order to see their strength. That’s why most ‘modern’ theories aren’t probed over and over again. Popular real-life example - doctor faked a study about vaccines causing autism, the medical community collectively studied and analysed the report and decided it was fake. If we took him for his word just cos he’s a smart guy… our children would have a plethora of diseases.
This isn’t abt someone’s religious acceptance or imaan. U’ve made a scientific claim and ur only backing for it is Dr. Zakir Naik. Who is maybe an extemely knowledgeable scholar of Islam and a doctor too - is he a scientist/biologist/medical researcher? No. So unless u prove what u said with real evidence, ppl will feel sorry for u.
Also - u have extremely weird views abt women in general. I would like to venture forth and say… u may possibly be a troll.
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
Zakir naik is a clown. Idk what you all are smoking.
He he is a perfect example of core ideology of Wahhabism and you know what Isis is a metastasized version of that. Find someone better to follow strangone - no wonder your ideas are wacko
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
A woman who has more than one husband will have several sexual partners at the same time and has a high chance of acquiring venereal or sexually transmitted diseases which can also be transmitted back to her husband even if all of them have no extra-marital sex. This is less likely in a man having more than one sexual partner, and none of them having extra-marital sex.
That’s a pretty basic thing to understand. If you’ll put different drinks in a single glass it will become a cocktail and you will not be able to understand/recognize or define it as a single drink but if you’ll put one drink in 100 different glasses it will still be considered as a one drink.
How educated and a wise man which is so cute and if I’m a troll then you’re a crud.
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
First of all it’s StangeWorld buttoned eyes
And you said you don’t believe in religion, did you forget that already?
You think all those billions of people who like and appreciate his wisdom are wrong and you alone are more wise and able to point out what is right and wrong right after claiming you don’t believe in religion or you’re not a religious person.
Do you really think you’re in a position to say anything like that?
Whatever he quotes is backed by pure Islamic commandments/background and his analysis of competitive religions has made world’s top Atheists, Christians, Hindus and Jews pee in their pants and if you don’t believe in Islam that’s your problem not mine.
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
I don’t believe in religion? Lol what? There is no cure for ignorance after all. Allah gave you brain, use it once in a while rather than blindly following the herd
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
Do Buddhists also PitP?
Re the 100 sources one glass vs one source hundred glasses analogy.
If the one sources is dipped into 100 glasses, and the glass contents can permeate through a semi permeable membrane enveloping the sources, coupled with travelling upstream via diffusion and some convection, could the single source get contaminated?
If either a man or woman have multiple sexual partners they have a higher liklihood of STDs. This is not something female specific. Are u sure ur not confusing paternity with STDs? Islam’s reasoning for women not marrying 4 men has to do with paternity/inheritance issues. Not STDs. If a woman has multiple partners, she will have a difficult time figuring out the father. Whereas it’s slightly easier for men cos they can’t get pregnant.
See, this is why people run from Islam. U have no idea what ur talking abt yet u still ramble on in each thread. Ur not a doctor. Or a scientist. Yet u’ve pinned Zakir Naik as the leading authority on all things science. We used to be a nation of thinkers…sad state.
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
DUDE thats not true!
Are you in medicine? Because if you are, you’d realize how stupid that sounds. AIDS became highlighted due to it’s correlation of spread with MSM (Men having sex with men). If a man sleeps with more than one woman, he CAN definitely transmit STDs to other women. The risk of transmission is actually HIGHEST in homosexual males, then heterosexual couples and then homosexual females. The reason why Islam allows for polygamy is because of the social setup (the need for making sure women were taken care off and not being sold into prostitution). The reason why Islam does not allow for polyandry (women having more than 1 husband) is due to paternity issues.
Whether we accept polygamy as Muslim women is a different debate. While Islam has allowed for polygamy, it does not pressurize women into accepting it and neither should anyone else.
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
I’m not in medicine neither a doctor but a medical doctor said that and I quoted his words. I know what you saying but we are talking about men who are not homosexual or having any STI’s or STD’s already developed in them. We are talking about clean people here.
I totally agree with you on the point why Islam allows polygamy and not polyandry.
In case of polyandry a female having intercourse with more than one men sounds something that can create diseases because even though she’s having clean sex with each of the clean partners the chances are sperms of previous partner didn’t die with in her body (according to science male sperms live for 72 hours) the time she’s having intercourse with her second sexual partner and so on. So having living sperms of multiple male sexual partners in her sexual organ (vagina) can easily create STD’s or STI’s for that matter.
But in case of polygamy when a man is having clean sex with multiple clean women at any given time there are very rare chances of carrying any sperms because men don’t have a sexual organ(vagina) and hence can’t carry or contain sperms.
Re: What are your thoughts on polygamous marriage/being a co-wife?
Ok so the problem is- you think that sperm carries STDs, that’s actually not true.
STDs can be carried by seminal OR vaginal fluids, so the risk of transmission is the same. In other words, if a guy is sleeping around with 4 women, he can transmit STDs to all 4 women. If a woman is sleeping around multiple men, she can infect others too.
I don’t know what you are referring to when you say clean. Straight men? Men with no STDs?
Also having “living sperm” does not “create” STDs!
