You seem to have missed the whole point Mr Popet!!!
If there was any hint of Prophethood after Prophet Mohammad (SAAW), then these Rightly Guided Caliphs might have not waged a war against them, they might have visited them and asked them to prove their prophet-hood...
The same way Christian & Jews did, they came to the Prophet Mohammad (SAAW) and asked him some question to prove his prophet-hood...
But he didn't saw anything of this sort from the Rightly Guided Caliphs... These Caliphs were the best Human Beings having the first hand knowledge and training of Islam from The Prophet (SAAW). They knew that, what ever the circumstances are, there is no Prophet After Prophet Mohammad (SAAW)...thats why they never hesitated to launch military campaigns against these False prophets.
Now, When Mirza Ghulam Ahmed Qadyan annouced his prophecy, Muslims were thrown out of Power, they had no control, nor did they had any army to kill such an imposter.. so the best they could have done is to challenge Mirza Ghulam Ahmed's Prophethood on intellectual level, and they did it, there were 10s of MANZARAS between the them... those debates i guess are still available and i believe that Mirza Ghulam Ahmed Qadayan was defeated (one way or other) in all His debates with the Right Ulemas of Islam.
Morevoer, In 1970s where there was movement to declare qadyanies non-muslim minority, a debate did took place with between the Ulemas of both sides and as the result of that debate, Qadayanies was decalared a non-muslim minority...
PS. Please refrain from accusing me and personal remarks, if you have any problem with any of my post, talk to moderators of the forum.
You must know very well why Jesus was rejected by Jews right?... or do i need to refresh your memory? Jews thought if Jesus AS is the right messiah he'll be saved from the cross. When they think they killed him, they said He was a false prophet.
Tell me more about Muslimah, what was his claim ? i'd like to know more about it please.
Apart from Muslimah and whoever else you talk about . They were them. This is Imam Mehdi AS here we are talkin about who Allah's messenger SAW himself spoke about. There is no way you should compare the earlier deceivers with the person which was foretold by Allah's Messenger SAW.
I do not miss any point sir. You 'fail' to understand where im actually coming from. You talk about Muslim power been taken away from them and hence they were unable to launch a campaign against them? are you kidding me? For the sake of deen, what is it that one cannot go for? It should not have been hard to kill a person claiming to be a false imam mahdi AS? Allah says He cut off his throat whoever lie in the name of Allah, why did Allah let go Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS? must be a special case , no? And beside, Mullahs surely did whatever they could to stop Him. They miserably failed. And beside, how could they have launched a campaign against him when the entire Ummah is all split up, causing them to have fights with each other and giving fatwas to eachother and calling eachother kaafir.
1970 year as u talk about was the year when Promised messiah's prohecy of 'causing thy message to reach the corners of the earth" had to be fulfilled. Had you have not declared them non-muslims, and they wud have been stucked in subcontinent only. Thank you for that. And look what Allah does to people who try to disobey the commandments of Allah.. see people like ziaul haq and bhutto. Learn the lesson yourself.
As far as having manazaras are concerned and defeating Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS, well, i dont know whether to laugh on it or to feel pity for you. Honestly, i feel like doing both. According to some of your well known scholars like Dr. Israr Ahmad and the son of Allama Iqbal,( do u really want me to quote that or you believe me on that.. please do believe or else ill have to dig out a video which you'll have hard time watching ) He AS was the one at those time who understood Islam to its fullest. According to Allama Iqbal (as i quote his son ), said that Allama iqbal said , if you want to see true islam, one must pay visit to Qadian. You talk about munazaraat.. if we as you say are being defeated this easily, why then are we not allowed to preach what we believe in , in Pakistan? why make us pray and have us fear for our lives? why dont you let the books of Ahmadiyyat publish openly? Let the truth inspire you my friend. Wake up and see whats happening around you and stop living a life which will take you no where and stop believing in a religion which encourages you to hate the people who love Muhammad SAW. Wake up as the message has been given to you , and unlock your heart and let the light of Quran pass by your locked heart. Believe in a religion Islam which will (if you continue to seek) lead you to the paths where our prophet Muhammad PBUH wants us to have. Believe in a religion which will make your status in Allah's eyes higher..
As Allama Iqbal says... khud ko kar buland itna ke har takdeer se pehle khuda bande se pooche ke bol teri raza kya hai.
PS: sorry hanibal, but this forum has its own politics going on too. You really think moderator like psyah will listen to me? nah! forget it.. i rather thought i'll directly come and ask you to stop using abusive language towards Ahmadiyya jamaat, which I hope you listen to, if you respect me as human being and respect my feelings. Thank you once again for coming back and replying me. I hope and pray to Allah to lead us both to the right path, whichever one it is. Aamin.