Weak Traditions associated with Ali ibn Abitalib KaramAllahwajho

[Das_Reich]

Re: Weak Traditions associated with Ali ibn Abitalib KaramAllahwajho

@Raj_ind

Thanks for ur valuable information bro.

I usually hear about the “Shujaat” of Ali, and about the bugz that other sahabis nurtured due to this quality of Ali. Pl let me know about its authenticity. And is it true that while other sahabis used to run during the hard times of wars, it was only Ali who fought bravely and was lone FATEH in all wars?

salam
I’m not sure if its all valuable yet, still waiting for the hadith experts to give their input here !
Its true that ALi and uthman were hated by certain sahaba because of tribal reasons or events that transpired later in the caliphate, I dont know of any who hated Ali because of his bravery.

And is it true that while other sahabis used to run during the hard times of wars, it was only Ali who fought bravely and was lone FATEH in all wars?

No not at all, but the extent of it is debatable as pro-Shia sources will exaggerate the role of Ali and pro-uthmani sources will downplay the role of ALi in Ghazwas.Generally though seerah and maghazi sources are written by individuals who dont have such clear bias and they give a balanced role of ALi and other companions.Its clear though that Ali played a pivotal role in battles of Badr & Khandaq and also in the campaign in Yemen ( largely overlooked in popular memory).But a lot of other sahaba also valiantly fought in the Ghazwas, and the islamic conquest of arabia was in no way solely due to Ali.