Weak Traditions associated with Ali ibn Abitalib KaramAllahwajho

[aqeel123]

Re: Weak Traditions associated with Ali ibn Abitalib KaramAllahwajho

@Das_Reich

^ Ok thats a good idea
I have no idea …btw some things are in Seerah and Maghazi not in Sahih hadith that does not automatically make them fabricated.Without magahzi a lot of details of battles will be lost,I was more interested traditions
E.g name of Ali’s horse sword etc might not be backed by a sahih chain but its no reason to deny that it false as a lot of details of magahzi are not.However if someone claims this sword had magical powers then for sure their is a** ulterior motive behind such a tradition and likely needs further investigation as its likely fabricated to project ALi over ABuBakr and Umar**.

@Das_Reich

^
1-I’m not a hafiz-e-Quran
2-this thread is not about quranic verses revealed in honor of certain companions that a whole seperate discussion
3-please dont derail this thread, by bringing the usual bs
4-If you know of any weak traditions to share about ALi then do so otherwise avoid this threAD

No offense to everybody else.

When Quran has called Ali Nafs of Rasool Allah s.a.w then there is no need to make up fabricated ahaadith to bring Ali a.s above abubakar or Umar. So dont write stuff that is unnecessary and you wont get un necessary responses. Lets stay of topic after this.