Re: Was she a muslim???
^ so what is the problem if this verse was revealed in madinah????
Quran itself says that Ibrahim (as) was allowed to pray for his father for a while but stopped later....
maybe the same was for abu talib....
cuz of the close affection with his uncle, it wud have been harsh for the prophet (saw) if he was told at once not to pray for his uncle (as the verse says cuz he is a companion of fire), but after time when the sorrow had faded, the verse was sent....
N.B. i am not claiming this to be true, just trying to give a logical explanation....