Re: Was Pakistan meant to be secular like India?
It would be helpful if people actually defined what a real islamic state would look like. Or at the very least, when did their real islamic state exist? In the absense of these, any talk of a real islamic state is meaningless.
Muslims could not keep an ideal, or as close to ideal as we can ever hope, islamic state for more than thirty years even though they had the best reformer that the world has ever seen. They were way better muslims than present day ‘ummah’.