Was Pakistan meant to be secular like India?

[the_kaur]

Re: Was Pakistan meant to be secular like India?

@ninja_hattori

you are clearly misrepresenting the facts…Yadavs are part of hindu religion if we talk about backward muslims we can show muslims more backward than yadavs..

Yadavs got OBC reservation they are part of obc…
Yadav are mainly from under developed states of UP and bihar while muslims about whom we are talking about are spread all over india…

Of you want to compare yadav please compare them with julaha or other caste of muslim community or at least with muslims from UP and bihar to get a clear picture…

And not getting beef is not my pain but it tells more about secular structure of india…
We are talking about hindu and muslim communities and suddenly you picked up a caste of hindus and compairing them muslims…like they are follower of some other religion…
P.S.yadavs are ruling class of UP and bihar…

Yadavs are available all over India as far as Andhra and TamilNadu, get your fact corrects, Muslim always try to present themselves as group which they are not. Syeds and Sheikhs are as good as Pundas and Baniyas even in bihar, Muslim Saudagars are famous for bussiness even before independence. Yadavs are assisted by muslims in UP and Bihar, Bihar had muslim CM much before Lalu. Mulayam’s Kursi’s three legs are muslims, Azam khan of Rampur is number two and will be acting CM in non availability of Akhilesh

Muslims are not group they also vote as hindu castes in UP where they are majority.Prosperity of Hindu barber and muslim barber is same. Hindu weaver is OBC just like Muslim Weaver. Syeds among muslims are most of the leader be it Imam-e-Jama Masjid or Syed Shanawaz Hussain of BJP, only prominent Pathan is Azam Khan. Querishi and Ansari are looked down upon by Syeds. Caste discrimination is muslims is as tough as Hindus. A syed never marries her daughter in Ansari in Kanpur. A Hindu Jamadar is same as Muslim Jamadar.
This is why no commision will be successful unless they study muslims caste pyramid, and none of commssion be it Sacchar or Rangnath misra commission explains why Ahemeddiyas have less than 5% in population have100% literacy and 90% of muslims who are sunni are less than 30%, I am sure Syed literacy would be more than 80%. similar to 100% literate brahmins, 65% graduates but still Hindu society is just 60% literate.
Financial position of Ashrafs is different from Ajlafs, Ashrafs are twice more richer than average Ajlaf. Now hindu Kasai and querishis are not different in prosperity. With such a consolidated vote in adverse situation, institutional discrimination is not even possible, in fact minorities have different institute where they are inducted in majority be it St Stephen’s delhi,AMU, Khalsa Collage.

@Southie

As for beef ban on Gandhi Jaynthi. Gandhiji would have been against it. Why bring religious practice into this.

Even liquor is banned on Gandhi Jayanti, so if deepawali on that day would be dry day, it hurts hindu celebration, hence proved Gandhian principles are anti thesis to religious sentiment and blot on India secular credentials:D

@muqawwee123

So Gandhi ji was not against the act of cow slaughter?

Gandhiji was against any type of killing, that is why Indians haven’t killed mosquitoes in 65 years even though it kills us:D