There is no contradiction. Please allow me to show you what contradiction really is…it is the belief of Jesus AS being alive, and on other hand saying every mortal shall taste death…contradiction is when you say He(AS) was a prophet but fail to accept him as God himself (since hes been living for 2000+ years). Contradiction, my friend , is when you regard Isa (AS) to be indirectly superior to Muhammad PBUH , since He (AS) will be the final prophet for mankind who will be doing such extraordinary tasks which Muhammad PBUH was unable to do in His (SAW)'s life. (naozubillah).
Regarding Muhammad PBUH to be the ‘final’ prophet BUT allow Jesus AS to come back is what contradiction is.
When those ‘villagers’ such as Sir Zafarullah Kahan sahab or Dr. Abdus salam see those contradictions, they have no choice but to kiss those beliefs goodbye, because they werent Islamic beliefs in the first place.
Get the contradictory answers from your aalims , sit back and enjoy your head spinning.