Viewpoints from Sindh

Those who know anything about Sindh, know that if PPP did not exist, the next most popular party would be jeay Sindh or it’s like among Sindhis, and it would be a similar situation like in Balochistan.

Interesting notes about PML Q chaudries and their tactics. I think it’s time for Mush to dump Q once and for all.

http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2008\01\08\story_8-1-2008_pg7_26

Ethnic tensions simmer in Pakistan after Benazir Bhutto’s killing

  • Mourner says evil forces trying to split Sindhis and Punjabis
  • Analyst says PPP’s rivals may capitalise on ethnic divide created after her death

GARHI KHUDA BUKSH: At Benazir Bhutto’s tomb the women wail, “Wake up, Sindhi!” — but the country could add ethnic strife to its other woes if the people of Pakistann’s southern province heed their call.

Sindh, the heartland of Benazir’s opposition party, saw the worst of a wave of rioting that erupted after her assassination on December 27, leaving nearly 60 people dead and causing hundreds of millions of dollars in damage. Fuelling the anger of ethnic Sindhis — and feeding conspiracy theories — was the fact that she died in Punjab province, Pakistanan’s richest and most populous province and home to the military and intelligence establishment.

Tensions between the array of ethnic and religious groups in Pakistan have boiled over several times in its troubled history, but have been largely quiet for the past half decade.

There are fears however that in the run-up to Pakistan’s delayed elections on February 18 the resentment among Sindhis — and attempts to capitalise on it by politicians in Punjab — could stoke the fires of hatred again. .

**“Benazir Bhutto was the only leader who could unite the four provinces. Now there are chances of a civil war,” **said Nazir Ahmad Arijo, a teacher paying his respects at the Bhutto family mausoleum in the village of Garhi Khuda Buksh.

Splitting people: **“The evil forces are trying their level best to split Sindhis and Punjabis and give this tragedy an ethnic edge. They want to divide and rule, that is why they killed our leader,” **the 32-year-old teacher added.

Here when people talk of “the Punjab”, it is often synonymous with the powerful army, dominated by Pakistanis from the central province. It also expresses decades-old resentment against its economic and political clout, stemming from when the country’s capital was moved from Karachi, the biggest city in both the province and the country, to Islamabad in the 1960s.

In Sindh the fury that saw hundreds of shops, banks and railway stations destroyed by mobs after Benazir died has eased, and** many now are keen to downplay initial anger that saw some rioters chanting anti-Punjabi slogans. **“Many Punjabis were murdered with Mohtarma (honorific term for Benazir). We don’t feel anger,” said fellow mourner Ishtiaq Ahmed, 20, referring to most of the 22 other people who died in the suicide and gun attack that killed her.

As hundreds gathered at the tomb, throwing rose petals and chanting slogans in support of Benazir’s Pakistan People’s Party (PPP), others said however that they now feared for the unity of the country of 160 million people. Saeed Ahmed Mangi, 22, said that not only Sindhis and Punjabis but also Pashtuns and Balochis “all liked her because she was the chain of the nations”.

Capitalising divides: Her popular appeal across the provinces could encourage the PPP’s political rivals to play the ethnic card to capitalise on underlying divisions, analysts said. With Musharraf loyalists already bringing up the issue ahead of the elections, analyst Hasan Askari said they would continue to use it to try to counter support for the PPP in Punjab. The Pakistan Muslim League-Quaid, which backs Musharraf, “plans to aggressively pursue the election campaign and play up the regional ethnic dimension to neutralise the PPP’s support in the Punjab,” he said.

Reports during the riots said that Punjabi businesses and homes were targeted by mobs in Sindh, but people from the province dismissed them.

**“The reports of anger against Punjabis is propaganda by the Q-League, the evil forces — you may call it the Punjabi establishment,” **mourner Arijo said.

Nationalist parties in Sindh also sought to play down the divisions, but at the same time they gave dire warnings about the future. “We all feel that after Benazir Bhutto’s murder, Pakistan may go towards disintegration,” said

Sabiha Arshad, local president

of the nationalist Khaksar

Tehreek Movement.

“But the Sindhi population is not of the view that we have to disintegrate from the country. Sindh is praying, ‘May God save Pakistan’,” she said over tea and cakes at her home in Larkana, Benazir’s ancestral town. Sabiha, who is also a medical doctor, said that there were close trade and cultural links between the two ethnic groups, ties that were bolstered by intermarriage.

She saved her blame for unspecified “foreign forces” allegedly meddling in Pakistan’s affairs, saying they would “try to make it (ethnicity) a burning issue to make it dangerous.” afp

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Now your talking sense.. But PML Q is the only party that will support Mush, so how can he dump them?

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Not to mention that just liked how ZAB used to refer to Ayub Khan as 'daddy', Altaf Hussain does the same thing with Chaudhry Shujaat.

PML[Q] and MQM are menaces, and they are the reason why Musharraf is a disilusioned, two bit, hated dictator now.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Is that why he is hated?

It’s not the failing economy, soaring corruption, or lack of democracy, or constraint judiciary. Now is it?

It’s the current official position taken by President Musharaff that rejects orthodox, militant, violent Islam that makes him an object of extreme hatred. Who hates Musharaff most, I don’t have to name the prime-suspect.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

I hate hime for failing economy, soaring corruption, lack of democracy, constrained judiciary, constrained media and the fact that his priority as COAS wasnt to tackle terrorists...

When it comes to the Taliban, Mush is quilty of putting his political agenda over his responsibilty in defending the country against terrorists....

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Indeeeeed! Thank you for a balanced read. Chaudhries are no better than the taleban in terms of their policies towards the people. Their intentions are just as bad. It’s about time Musharraf cleaned up his cabinet and took a closer look at the workings of his advisors. I’m all for a new setup, if he still wants to win people back and them to support him, he needs to dump Q League, dis-unite from MQM and set forth fair terms on which politicians will be wooed to join him. An honest PM like Aitzaz Ahsan, a fair minister of Foreign Affairs like Imran because lets face it, the guy speaks better than most and whatever else he lacks, he’ll learn when he’s on the team and besides he’ll be carrying the nation’s message, not his own.
And a few other names that i can’t think of for the lack of their background would be good for the new team to accel forward.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Your statement is self-contradictory.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Interesting.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Aiteraaz Ahsan and honest? That's some nice selected reading of history.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

And the important point about this article is that why for over 60 years Sindh and rest of Pakistan feels so much contempt towards the Punjabi establishment. We can no longer hide this as we used to in the past. It is all out in the open now. Time to ask some tough questions.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

So ask tough questions! Head on over to GHQ....i've been saying that all along.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

He's better than most others that are contending to be in the politics at the moment. He's educated, he's innocent yet still in Jail. He knows the law;therefore, would mostly likely follow it and not cherry pick and change constitution like the current regime.

Thanks for pointing that out and listening.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Tough questions are for punjabis to ask themselves. What have they been doing for the last 60 years? What were they doing in 1971? Why have their leaders worked only for punjab and not rest of pakistan? Other ethnicities will ask their own tough questions to themselves.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Last time i checked Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was a Pakistani, so was BB, so are all the people right now. Unfortunately, MQM was the first party to play the 'ethnic' card, and now others are following that mentality such as PML(Q) members. No one else has said such hateful stuff to cause rifts between ethnicities and provinces as have those two so-called parties, i see them more like groups. Their behavior certainly shows the immaturity, which shouldn't be present for a political party that wants to eventually become national. PPP became national because it worked for all the common folks of Pakistan, all of them. MQM has been cordoned off in Karachi and Hyderabad because it chooses to stay concentrated so it can pass on heinous remarks that play on the emotions of people all over pakistan. All the people are hurt by BB's assassination. If you were any smarter you'd be asking for unity of all people, not to point fingers at the common man because the middle-class and poor of the country know no hatred, they know no ethnicities. It's the Elite class like Altaf Hussain who sits in London, Nawaz who is now back, Zardari who is..somewhere, Generals (who might i remind you, have the country by it's throat), and petty politicians such as Chaudhries who also play on the emotions of people to cause more hurt rather than console and comfort people. MQM could have PM contenders too if it decides to grow up and quit whining all the time.

It's Pakistan as a whole that hurts if something happens, and benefits as a whole if something good comes from anything. Don't hate a province just because it is bigger. Please don't be so naive, and speak intellectly. You're much too racial in my view, and from the posts of yours it's obvious you wish no good for the people either. I think it's time that you asked yourself some tough questions!....Thanks for your kind words and provocative but petty remarks.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

Sad to say you know nothing about the history of Pakistan. I suggest you read about the likes of GM Syed, Bacha Khan, Khan of Kalaat, Mujib-ur-Rehman before you come back here. Thank you.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

I suggest the same for you too.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

People of Punjab should accept the minorites and gave them proper respect, otherwise I don't see United Pakistan in near future. Time to ask our self some tough questions..this is the last chance which qudraat is giving us. May Allah save us.

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

teggy, So you admit that thus line was a blatant lie than?

[QUOTE]
Unfortunately, MQM was the first party to play the 'ethnic' card,
[/QUOTE]

Re: Viewpoints from Sindh

I respect all people and as far as i know all the common people have no hard feelings, or hatred. It's a chosen bunch of elites that make it to the politics that cause rifts.

I've lived in Karachi and see its people and its potential as that of any leading metropolitan. But it needs to free itself of one party rule if u know what i mean.