What Iâm failing to understand is why anyone would have religious/modesty expectations from a girl who asked them to watch porn with her, and then moreover who agreed to do that with her in the first place? It seems odd these things would be important to the OP, because what modesty was shown at the onset of the relationship?
OP, I think you already set her expectations at the beginning that youâre highly sexually open, and so she probably figured you fit well with her lifestyle of being out there and open with guys (multiple male facebook friends, lots of pics, etc). So then for you to to ask her to be more modest, dupatta, etc, in her mind is you doing a 180 on her.
This is why I say you gotta figure out what youâre all about, and what you want.
Are you a sexually liberal guy and you are looking for a sexually liberal girl? Because that means she will be sexually liberal so she will post pictures of herself a lot, will have lots of guy friends, will have a flirty nature, and wonât find anything wrong with it. Her thought is, if sexually open guys can do it, why canât I?
Or are you looking for someone who has a traditional outlook? Dedicates herself to her husband, cuts down on contact with guy friends, and will be receptive to a dupatta or hijab? In which case, if thatâs the kind of girl you want, then itâs only logical that you too be modest. Watching porn with a stranger is not modest. So mistakes happen, ok, fine, but is that your pattern? You only know the answer to these things, not us, and you donât have to answer this, but ask the question to yourself.
How open are you sexually, and if itâs your right as a man, then as a woman, what is her right? Why be surprised when she exhibits open sexual behavior? If this is unsettling to you, then should you expect more modesty out of yourself in the future?
I once went to this talk where the Imam said some guy came up to him and said âImam, I really hope to meet a girl who is like Aisha (R)â. So he said to the guy âWell then you better be like Muhammad (SAW)â.