US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

It’s official now, perhaps US energy secretary was in India to convey mainly this message.
With American opposition, consider this project as dead.

I think India has to pay some price for nuclear deal…although Nuclear energy is a better option but for fulfilling immediate energy requirement this gas pipeline was the best, besides India is facing hard competition with bigger nations like China for securing oil and gas fields in other countries.


Thursday, March 22, 2007 (New Delhi):
The United States has informed the Indian government that it is opposed to the building of a pipeline to carry gas from Iran to India via Pakistan, US Energy Secretary Samuel Bodman said.

“During my trip, I have made it clear at the highest levels of the Indian government that the US opposes the development of the Iranian pipeline to India,” he said.

Bodman, in India on a three-day official visit, told Dow Jones Newswires in an interview that the US opposition to the project was linked to concerns about Iran’s nuclear programme.

Asked why the US is opposed to the pipeline, Bodman said, “We believe that Iran is seeking to develop nuclear weapons, and anything that will support that endeavour is something that we oppose.”

India favours diplomatic efforts to resolve the standoff on Iran’s nuclear programme.

Iran, India and Pakistan are engaged in negotiations to build a pipeline that will supply Iranian gas to Pakistan and India to meet their rapidly growing energy needs.

The proposed 2,600-km pipeline will give Iran an additional outlet for its vast natural gas reserves, estimated to be about 812 trillion cubic feet.

The pipeline will cost an estimated eight billion dollars.

http://www.ndtv.com/morenews/showmorestory.asp?slug=US+opposes+gas+pipeline+from+Iran+to+India&id=102436&category=National

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

I sincerely hope this project comes through- it'll boost both Indian and Pak economies.. The cost of petrol is sky-high in these countries and inflation is really bad too.

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

*The United States has informed the Indian government that it is opposed to the building of a pipeline to carry gas from Iran to India via Pakistan, US Energy Secretary Samuel Bodman said.
*

Well, that's just typical.

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

The US has nothing more in mind than to stifle every modicum of business and economical progress anywhere in the world except itself...

I too hope this pipeline goes through...Mutual cooperation between the regional entities will ensure a peaceful and progressive atmosphere amongst neighbouring countries...Not that it will happen if uncle Sam has any say in this regard...

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

who do you think has been providing arms to the Baluch nationalists? Is there any truth in that conspiracy theory?

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

well if India opts out, then Pakistan we can build it between Pakistan and Iran

Actually I am happy, India is pulling out, it will push Iran to our camp rather than India

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

^ Iran is a country with a great civiliazation, a vibrant past and a rich history. They have very cordial relations with India dating many centuries back, so to think that an agreement gone foul would throw Iran into our camp would be quite naive.

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

Todays relationships are purely based on "interest" nothing to do with culture, history, love etc.... Iran is a growing regional power and it has to look out for its interests.

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

I doubt even Pakistan will go ahead alone for following reasons:

(1) Cost of project is in billion dollars, also without India Pakistan will loose the revenue generated due to transit fee.
(2) Pakistan is more aligned to US policies than India, some times back US has given Pak the status of non-Nato ally. So definately American green signal will be one thing which Pak will be forced to consider.

On a seperate note, India pursues an independent foreign policy and still considers Iran as a nation with whom both share ancient cultural bond and also strategic importance to relation with Iran.
In this case also, India could have cared less about US objections had it not been to Nuclear deal which is still under negotiation stage.

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

Abdali: " Todays relationships are purely based on "interest" nothing to do with culture, history, love etc.... Iran is a growing regional power and it has to look out for its interests."

that was just by the by, just to put the argument in perspective. What I meant was that just because of a disagreement on some issue, they would not join this camp or that. Its about the larger interests which can't be defined on such narrow terms.

However, having said that, you are absolutely correct. Didn't we see India voting for the IAEA resolution against Iran? :)

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

No...i dont think so. There are central asian countries, whose population is much smaller than pakistan get their natural gas from Russia. when they can go alone, pakistan can also go alone. pakistan will only loose transit fee!

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

i dont know when was iran in our camp in the first place eventhough political relations were quiet normal. and it is not cold war also to get someone into either camps. But still, whether they were in our camp or your camp, i would still like this pipeline to go ahead

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

How much is the transit fee?

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

^^600 million dollars a year

http://english.people.com.cn/200503/20/eng20050320_177516.html

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

I don't understand why you all hating on the states.. the truth is that the US does not get along with Iran.. and the US is making huge exceptions to have a nuclear deal with India.. OFCOURSE in that case they don't want India to build close economic ties with Iran.. I would do the same if I was the states..

From India's point of view, they should present their acute oil problem to the states and b like YO WE NEED THIS SHYTE THE NUCLEAR DEAL WITH YOU AINT GONNA START GIVING US RESULTS ANYTIME SOON SO EITHER YOU LET US USE YOUR HOOKUPS WITH CANADA OR MEXICO N GET US MORE OIL DEALS CUZ OUR HOOKUPPS IN THE MIDDLE EAST AINT WORKIN OUT... ORR STFU AND LET US BUILD THE PIPELINE..

From Pak's point of view.. I understand they would recieve transit fees.. So isn't it in Pakistan's interest to have this built? It's not like just because of this pipeline the oil flow from Iran to Pak wud b affected, would it?

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

I wonder what Iran will do if it loses India and Pakistan as valuable allies....

Cause no Arab countries like Iran...

Only China and Russia are chummy chummy with Iran and thats only because of oil

So besides Venezuela, what true friends does Iran have in this world?

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

nuclear energy is not gas energy, theres needs for both. id be very suprised if india now refuse the gas from iran having secured the deal

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

the nuclear deal is more important for the Indians than the gas deal. The former places India on a much different level, at par with the rest of the elite club than the latter. I am not too sure whether India has become member of NSG yet but once it has secured the deal with the US, it will reap a lot of benifits. Now the test is whether it will be able to maintain its independence or not...

Given the recent developments in and around Iran, that is highly unlikely and I don't think India will chose to antagonize the US.

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

The concept of a super power is intrinsically undemocratic. The essence of democracy lies in accountability, i.e. each Nation-State is responsible for its actions to its people or the electorate. If the government performs well, in accordance with the aspirations of its electorate, it can be elected again and again, if not, it can be overthown in the next election.

This system of checks and balances, where the electorate keeps a check on the powers of the government, works well for ordinary Nation-States. But a Super-State is somewhat different from other Nation-States vis-à-vis its authority and sphere of influence extends beyond its borders. Now when the Super-State governs not only itself but also, in practice, many other nations too, we come up with a paradox. The authority of the Super-State extends to many nations while it is responsible only to its own citizens or electorate.

Now what business does US has in the affairs of Iran, Pakistan and India?

Re: US opposes gas pipeline from Iran to India

You cannot have your cake and eat it too... You need to read the text of the deal to know what I am talking about.