US crushes Pak hopes on Kashmir

While I found the title amusing :), the shift in US policy (or should I say reverting back to its old policy) is interesting. Looks like better sense prevailed on Obama…

Bad news for folks who were hoping the US would help in separating Kashmir from India.

====================================================

TIMESNOW.tv - Latest Breaking News, Big News Stories, News Videos -

In a major shift in the policy of United States toward Kashmir, the government of US says Kashmir is a wholly an internal matter of India and Washington has no role in solving it.

It seems like Washington is going to leave Pakistan out in the cold on the Kashmir issue. The US government spokesperson Robert Wood on Wednesday (January 28) clarified its stand on Kashmir, saying it was not part of their country’s mandate.

The news comes as a severe blow to Islamabad which has long called for Washington to mediate on the contentious problem of Kashmir. On the other hand, this comes as welcome news for India which has always sought to tackle the Kasmir issue bi-laterall with no international interference.

**Implications of the statements **

The implications of the statements coming out of the White House firstly make it clear that the US will not mediate on Kashmir. This clearly indicates that the issue will continue to be an internal matter for the Indian government.

Pakistan will have to deal directly with India since it is a bi-lateral matter without an external influence.

The statements finally make it clear that separatist leaders can no longer hope to internationalize the matter.

The United States has made it clear that its newly appointed special envoy on Afghanistan and Pakistan - Richard Holbrooke - has no mandate to deal with Kashmir and his sole job is to help bring stability to Afghanistan.

During the campaign, President Obama was pretty clear that he thought to solve South Asia’s problems, you need a very collective approach, and he talked a lot about Kashmir. It doesn’t sound like Holbrooke’s mandate is trying to mediate between India and Pakistan.

Robert Wood, Spokesman of US government, said that it was not in his mandate to deal with the subject of Kashmir, and that his mandate is to go out and try to help bring stability to Afghanistan, working closely with Pakistan to try to deal with the situation in the FATA region."

Speaking on the issue of Kashmir, Robert Wood, said, “With regard to Kashmir, I think our policy is well-known. I think India has some very clear views as to what it wants to do vis-à-vis, you know, dealing with the Kashmir issue, as well as the Pakistanis. But with regard to Ambassador Holbrooke’s mission, as I said, it’s to deal strictly with the Pakistan-Afghanistan situation.”

Re: US crushes Pak hopes on Kashmir

why is all this not surprising!!!!!

Without looking at the article I can bet its Indian media/reporter?

Re: US crushes Pak hopes on Kashmir

^ It is :rotfl: Infact, looks like an anti-pakistani tabloid to me. Punjabi indian, you gotta stop laughing at your own jokes mon.

Maybe angreji poor hai hindustani reporters ki. All he said was that that particular ambassador to Afghanistan or whatever had nothing to do with Kashmir.

Re: US crushes Pak hopes on Kashmir

:omg: :omg: :omg:
Not a surprise that this news is in Indian Media only. :hmmm:
Proof is in the pudding.

kashmir Robert Wood - Google Search

:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:

Wed, Jan 28 01:47 PM
It is in America’s interest to see that the Kashmir issue is resolved but the country can only encourage India and Pakistan to work towards a solution, a senior Democrat and head of a prestigious US-based think tank has said.
Lee Hamilton, vice-chairman of the 9/11 Commission and now president of the prestigious Washington-based think tank, Woodrow Wilson Centre for Scholars, has argued it is in US’s interest to resolve the Kashmir issue, which he said would require tough diplomacy.
Appearing on the popular Charlie Rose show on PBS channel, Hamilton however said the US cannot resolve the issue and can only encourage both the countries to do so.
“We certainly need to work with Pakistan and India to resolve the Kashmir problem. The United States can’t resolve that, but we can encourage the two parties to address it,” Hamilton said.
A Democrat, Hamilton served in the US House of Representatives for as many as 34 years.

Conflicting Stories…internet can be funny…:gs:

Dissing the article is not going make the facts change :) Holbrooke is the ambassador to Afghanistan **and Pakistan, **who was "expected" to be the US man responsible for mediation in the Kashmir issue.

Now, US has clearly spelt out that his mandate does not include Kashmir.

For you Mo … straight from the “horses mouth”

Daily Press Briefing - January 27

QUESTION: A question regarding Richard Holbrooke. During the campaign, President Obama was pretty clear that he thought to solve South Asia’s problems, you need a very collective approach, and he was – he talked a lot about Kashmir. It – from what – it doesn’t sound like Holbrooke’s mandate is trying to mediate between India and Pakistan. Is that right? And, if so, why not, because everyone sort of agrees that is the fundamental issue in that region?

**MR. WOOD: **Well, it’s not in his mandate, as you mention, to deal with the subject of Kashmir. His mandate is to go out and try to help bring stability to Afghanistan, working closely with Pakistan to try to deal with the situation in the FATA region. With regard to Kashmir, I think our policy is well-known. I think India has some very clear views as to what it wants to do vis-à-vis, you know, dealing with the Kashmir issue, as well as the Pakistanis. But with regard to Ambassador Holbrooke’s mission, as I said, it’s to deal strictly with the India-Pakistan – excuse me – the Pakistan-Afghanistan situation

%between%

  1. Thats the unofficial opinion :slight_smile:
  2. Where is the link ??

Re: US crushes Pak hopes on Kashmir

pakistanis eagerly poking their nose into kashmir valley while swat valley is lost.

oh obama sir please help us from evil india..

SO why are Indians trying to conncet him to Kashmir? My my my, one spin after the other… There are rumors about Bill Clinton being considered Special Envoy on Kasmeer.

^ The question was not posed by an Indian :slight_smile:

And read the question again on why the connection to “Kasmeer”. Hint: Its the part in bolded font :wink:

You still waiting for "Bill" .... good luck to you :biggthumb

SO just because of the bold para Indians connected kasmeer mandate to Holbrooke.. LMAO…

Here is what Obama said versus what Indians are saying.

BBC NEWS | South Asia | Obama’s Kashmir conundrum

Bill Clinton role?

Yet in that same interview with Time magazine, Mr Obama held open the prospect that his administration would get involved in sorting out Kashmir and might even send a high profile envoy.

Re: US crushes Pak hopes on Kashmir

Congratulations India now all your problems in Kashmir is over because uncle sam wont take up the issue and get involved.....like it has for the last 60 years

HAHAHAHA

Well i don’t see “Bill” Clinton coming soon … but “Billy” Clinton does not mince any words when she says … “But there’s little doubt in anyone’s mind that the border areas between Afghanistan and Pakistan are a source of instability for Afghanistan, for Pakistan, and far beyond the borders of those two countries” …

Hope you understand what that means … oh this one is from “credible” Pakistani media so you cannot blame it on the messanger also …

http://www.dawn.net/wps/wcm/connect/Dawn%20Content%20Library/dawn/news/world/concern-conveyed-to-zardari-karzai-clinton–bi

This interview was done ages ago - the press briefing is recent. Politicians say a lot of things, but when the rubber hits the road they sing a different tune. :slight_smile:

Welcome to the real world !!

The US never was a problem for us :slight_smile: The problem is created by our neighbors.:wink:

This discussion is about Kasmeer and big bad phoren hand in kasmeer, not about Afghan/Pak… Obama said he will get involved, I’d say let him get his feet wet before you Indians go apes jumping up and down spinning tales.

Spinning as usual are we, he just took office would you give him time and see what he does. The key is, is it in amreekan interest in geting this out of the way, If yes then yes he will if not then america don't give two hoots about kasmeeer. Wait and see.