Re: Undivied India
more muslims don't live in India, i don't know why people keep saying that. when did that myth start becoming so popular.
Re: Undivied India
Chinese View and they believe it can be done if China gets involved.
NEW DELHI, India—Almost coinciding with the 13th round of Sino-Indian border talks (New Delhi Images](http://search.rediff.com/imgsrch/default.php?MT=delhi) ], August 7-8, 2009), an article (in the Chinese language) has appeared in China captioned ‘If China takes a little action, the so-called Indian Federation can be broken up’ (Zhong Guo Zhan Lue Gang, www.iiss.cn](http://www.iiss.cn/), Chinese, August 8, 2009).
Re: Undivied India
why do people here want india broken up and not united, what exactly do china and pakistan get from that??? and let's be childish and pray then that pakistan must be broken up too, how would any of that be good for the region.
it's utterly imbecilic
Re: Undivied India
Hi yall,
undivided India is not possible since it has already been divided. If you're talking about re-unification, it is a good idea because we can together become a very strong world power. For India, this will release a lot of resources now being spent on guarding the border, defending Kashmir etc. For Bangladesh, this will bring them out of a flood-prone 4th world situation into a more successful country. For Pakistan, same as India, they can release all the resources now spent on defense as well. Afghanistan will regain her glory as well as part of Greater india and can successfully resist Arabic extremism (for example OBL)
More importantly:
1) Western countries will no longer be able to divide and rule the sub-continent for any reason
2) Minorities will be strengthened thus making democracy stronger
3) Terrorism will have no hope of sanctuary - even if the Arabs want to house them here anymore
Even on simple matters such as textile export, cricket, hockey etc we can field a world #1 posture. Just imagine Tendular, Sehwag, Inzimam & Akhtar in one team! Can the Aussie loudmouths stand a chance?
It is a win win win win proposition. It is very difficult to achieve given the current state of affairs but we can always hope and pray!
Re: Undivied India
but India and Pakistan can be friends !
I am all up for that. Let us all keep working to that end.
Its called rasi jaal gai per baal nahin gia...
What do you want to say . Please say it in plain language.
my views are that the split was not enough, India needs further splitting into 6-7 more smaller states to fix it.
Why do you thing so ? What is wrong with present India ?
If you're talking about re-unification, it is a good idea because we can together become a very strong world power.
Dream on.
Re: Undivied India
Why do you thing so ? What is wrong with present India ?
why i think so? because a chotta panda will not have enough of power to abuse its neighbors as bad as its bigger and stinkier version is doing for last 6 decades, that's why.
Re: Undivied India
why i think so? because a chotta panda will not have enough of power to abuse its neighbors as bad as its bigger and stinkier version is doing for last 6 decades, that's why.
Israel is a chotta panda , but it is abusing its neighbors , so what do you have to say about it ?
What is your next argument ?
Re: Undivied India
Israel is a chotta panda , but it is abusing its neighbors , so what do you have to say about it ? What is your next argument ?
that panda has a big bowl at its back, plus that one is a bit too far to deal with, at least at this stage. let us first take care of the closer one, and punch some holes in the big bowls behind that chota panda then we will see israel as well, and it will need only one fire cracker anyway
Re: Undivied India
that panda has a big bowl at its back, plus that one is a bit too far to deal with, at least at this stage. let us first take care of the closer one, and punch some holes in the big bowls behind that chota panda then we will see israel as well, and it will need only one fire cracker anyway
Now you have gone into some kind of trance so I cannot have a discussion with you anymore. Allah Hafiz.
Re: Undivied India
i was not having any discussion by the way, i was just stating some facts and giving my PERSONAL opinion which the thread opener asked for : ) aapka bhee ALLAH HAFIZ
Re: Undivied India
Hi yall,
undivided India is not possible since it has already been divided. If you're talking about re-unification, it is a good idea because we can together become a very strong world power. For India, this will release a lot of resources now being spent on guarding the border, defending Kashmir etc. For Bangladesh, this will bring them out of a flood-prone 4th world situation into a more successful country. For Pakistan, same as India, they can release all the resources now spent on defense as well. Afghanistan will regain her glory as well as part of Greater india and can successfully resist Arabic extremism (for example OBL)
More importantly:
1) Western countries will no longer be able to divide and rule the sub-continent for any reason 2) Minorities will be strengthened thus making democracy stronger 3) Terrorism will have no hope of sanctuary - even if the Arabs want to house them here anymore
Even on simple matters such as textile export, cricket, hockey etc we can field a world #1 posture. Just imagine Tendular, Sehwag, Inzimam & Akhtar in one team! Can the Aussie loudmouths stand a chance?
It is a win win win win proposition. It is very difficult to achieve given the current state of affairs but we can always hope and pray!
India was one country before as we know and the british Raj was very clever they made us fight each other and become divided.
When you divided by colonial power it is for one reason only to weaken you so you can be controlled.
In current climate it not possible too much suspicion and lack of trust on both parties.
In future who knows anything possible germany used to be east and west germany now they one country and economic powerhouse.
Re: Undivied India
In future who knows anything possible germany used to be east and west germany now they one country and economic powerhouse.
this is wrong example, they were one nation, they had one religion, same customs, same beliefs... in case of pakistan and india, all these things are different, Religion is the deciding force in a muslim's world. Quwat-e-mazhab say mustahkam hay jamiyat teri!
Re: Undivied India
this is wrong example, they were one nation, they had one religion, same customs, same beliefs... in case of pakistan and india, all these things are different, Religion is the deciding force in a muslim's world. Quwat-e-mazhab say mustahkam hay jamiyat teri!
so for fellows like you the fight is between hindus and muslims, unfortunately that fight is not happening inside India, long ago Gandhi took that fight for me, he helped in forming Indian states based upon language ! a language Pakistan never learnt to respect thus the creation of Bangladesh ! and respect other religion.
Re: Undivied India
so for fellows like you the fight is between hindus and muslims, unfortunately that fight is not happening inside India, long ago Gandhi took that fight for me, he helped in forming Indian states based upon language ! a language Pakistan never learnt to respect thus the creation of Bangladesh ! and respect other religion.
ok so you are saying that provinces/ states should only be based on language? may be true, but what it has to do with undivided india? why not a step further and release those states from bigotry and declare them as independent countries?
and, in your books language comes before religion? right, good for you. this is not the case for us muslims, religion comes first, language is only a means of communication. see this difference? this is good enough of a reason to have india divided.
Re: Undivied India
My take on this is that India has always been divided... it's not called a subcontinent for no reason.
That said it's not exactly a bad thing being made up of seperate mini states, at the end of the day it's probably the best system.
Re: Undivied India
this is wrong example, they were one nation, they had one religion, same customs, same beliefs... in case of pakistan and india, all these things are different, Religion is the deciding force in a muslim's world. Quwat-e-mazhab say mustahkam hay jamiyat teri!
Well india was also under mughal rule many hundreds of years where different religion co existed and india was rich beyond our dreams, some would argue it was bad time it depends on your viewpoint.
Under islam people have right to practice own religion.
Re: Undivied India
Javed bhai the Mughal era was India's high water mark.
Personally i think it's best to let old bones lie... just as life is followed by death... so India must face it's divisions.
Re: Undivied India
Well india was also under mughal rule many hundreds of years where different religion co existed and india was rich beyond our dreams, some would argue it was bad time it depends on your viewpoint.
Under islam people have right to practice own religion.
answer to your post is in itself, read the bold parts.
Re: Undivied India
I think we should have stayed united.
there are no "should-s" there in the equation.
If we had done pakistan more gracefully, no one would be asking this question.
Its like barren wife and impotent talking "we should not have gotten married"
of course you moron if you did not have ball to make marriage work.. you shouldn't have..
Re: Undivied India
Javed bhai the Mughal era was India's high water mark.
Personally i think it's best to let old bones lie... just as life is followed by death... so India must face it's divisions.
India is an artifical state, the brits left in a hurry and why would they care to take care of the problem. The division was natural and was just a matter of time.