Undivided India

Society Pakistan & World Affairs
1

What are your views on India being split up into more portions that lead to India, Pakistan, Burma and Bangladesh… do you think India would have been better if we didnt divide?

2

Re: Undivied India

If India would not have been split then today More Muslims, Christistians and other minorities were being killed by Hindus

3

Re: Undivied India

What is your plan McLovin ? Dreaming of Akahand Bharat ?

4

Re: Undivied India

I think we should have stayed united.

5

Re: Undivied India

1- Define better.

2- 'We' who?

6

Re: Undivied India

To me, it seems a dreadful indignity to have a soul controlled by geography.

7

Re: Undivied India

hammad78,

Since partition millions more Muslims have been killed in Pakistan than in India. Go ask a Bangladeshi.

Today Muslims are more scared to go to their mosques in Pakistan than in India. Ask Shias who participate in their julooses, ask Sufi worshipers at Data darbar , ask Ahmadis..

Our extremists demolished a empty mosque. Yours bomb mosques full of namaazis.

I wonder how many non-Panjabi/non-Muhajir members are on this site. Is there any member who doesn't have a single relative/friend in Pak Army.

Having said that I don't wish for a Akhand Bharat. What is done is done. Pakistani leaders should now take care of their own people. Worry about their health, sanitation, education,etc.

Similarly, the rights of ethnic minorities like Pashtuns, Balochis, Seraikis, Baltistanis shouldn't be trampled. Only then a united and strong Pakistan is possible.

Otherwise, the days of "Loy Afghanistan" are not far !

8

Re: Undivied India

This indeed is a sad reality facing us. I believe what is done, is done. It is not wise to think about undoing the Partition of India for it would create more problems than solve. All countries that have come to exist out of an Undivided India must exist in their own right and progress independently.

I am a Pakistan and I don't think you are wishing for an Akhand Bharat.

9

Re: Undivied India

Nope. Its called revisionist history which is very common amongst so called Pakistani intelligentsia today. Usually the rich alcohol drinking idiots who are completely disconnected with the nation and its realities. Ask the average Pakistani and they would smack you up side the head of such a dumb ass question.

But then again this is not a Pakistani forum. Pakdef is.

10

Re: Undivied India

Its called rasi jaal gai per baal nahin gia...

11

Re: Undivied India

na nope never, i don't know why it always goes back to partition times. It's something that happened during our grandparents time and yet we keep bringing it up. can we just move on. It's this annoying issue of trying to pull the other country down that's been a major problem in the region and the K word and not partition happening. thank the lord all these countries are separate and independent.

if the two countries would stop with the "Pakistan did it" or "RAW agents did it" childish blame game and progress on their own, i'm pretty sure both countries, including bangladesh would be doing a lot better.

something similar to european union is just not possible now but maybe in the distant distant future when all these countries work together for the betterment of the region as a whole.

12

Re: Undivied India

O mankind! Lo! We have created you male and female, and have made you nations and tribes that ye may know one another. Lo! the noblest of you, in the sight of Allah, is the best in conduct. Lo! Allah is Knower, Aware. Surah al-Hujurat (49:13)

Quaid Message:

We are a nation with our own distinctive culture and civilization, language and literature, art and architecture, names and nomenclature, sense of values and proportion, legal laws and moral code, customs and calendar, history and tradition, aptitudes and ambitions; in short, we have our own distinctive outlook on life and of life. By all canons of international law, we are a nation".

I think these two quotations serve as a reminder as to why people, nations, tribes, and others are different and people should be accepting of each others differences. Whats in the past is past.

13

Re: Undivied India

but India and Pakistan can be friends !

14

Re: Undivied India

my views are that the split was not enough, India needs further splitting into 6-7 more smaller states to fix it.

15

Re: Undivied India

It is good in thinking but not practical... when India is busy in supporting the anti-state factors ( most of the time creating them) then no state can consider India as its friend, be it Nepal, Srilanka or Pakistan.. Indian priorities are set to get the left over india divided into another 5 or 6 states..

16

Re: Undivied India

While I do not dispute most of your post, to act as though the only extremist crime against Muslims in India was the destruction of a single empty mosque is beyond "revisionist".

I personally think it would be a good thing for India to be divided up into maybe 4 countries: it is just so big and so diverse and unwieldy.

17

Re: Undivied India

Could you please try and come up with a more stupid question?

18

Re: Undivied India

nobody is asking about your opinion if remaining india should be divided again? but some pakistani people are very much eager to divide it in more parts, what a pathetic thinking ,always thinking against india , where more muslims are living than pakistan and have more freedom of religious practices ,

19

Re: Undivied India

LMAO! Typical Indian propaganda. Please prove more Muslims live in India? Hell considering current population demographics more Muslims live in Bangladesh than India.

20

Re: Undivied India

Yeah, we're working on something like that. hindustan is a huge country so theres gonna be another Pakistan, a Khalistan and a Maoist Nation to the east. Gonna be pretty cool.