Two-Nation Theory v Most Favoured Nation (MFN) Status

[the_kaur]

Re: Two-Nation Theory v Most Favoured Nation (MFN) Status

@The_Jinx

You need to get your history lessons retaken and corrected. The two-nation theory was presented by Sir Syed Ahmed Khan the very first time. And no, Quaid did not use that theory the second time. It was well supported by Allama Iqbal and because of Iqbal and Quaid’s experience with All India Congress, he was fully convinced that the theory holds water.

Experience and drawing conclusion from it differs among people, I am glad to have history teacher in you:), Iqbal supported two nation theory or he asked for loose confederation of Muslim state within domain of India? I don’t know why Jinnah’s experience was different from Maulana Abul Kalam and Baccha Khan, nevertheless I am satisfied with the theory but not the way it was implemented:) I hope when human starts populating another planet our countries should migrate to seprate solar systems may be then we can have peace:)

@Captain1

You have to go back to 1940s to learn that.

When and who wrote that agreement? Muslims all over India supported separate state so why would they not go to state which they supported? People kept coming to Pakistan till late 60s, yes, does that mean everyone was able to afford to migrate? No. Does that mean everybody was ready to move? No. Does that mean everybody wanted to move? No. Does that mean Muslims were harassed in different part of India with same intensity as in 1947? No.

Anymore questions?

Good one, appreciate it:k:

@Ali_Syed

This is factually not correct most of the migration took place from the areas which were divided like Punjab and Bengal. The proportion of Muslims in undivided punjab before partition was around 60% and even now if you see the population of Pakistani Punjab is about 60 % of the current undivided Punjab. The difference is that there are no Hindus and Sikhs on our side and no Muslims on your side.

Of course comparing both countries is faulty, India was almost five times bigger then, and comparatively migration took place completely. Partition was most severe only in Punjab because Hindus and Muslims kept on living both in Sindh,Bengal and Baluchistan:)