Well said :k:
I am not going to take an applogetic stand to whatever humming bird said. He/She can debate that with you.
You on the other hand, being a Hindu said that Islam needs reform and also that Hinduism philosophy is superior to Abrahamic religions. And Yes, being a Muslim, I will point this out every time someone says it.
Remember that you are on a Muslim majority forum, so do not come here to mock, belittle Islam or detail a thread.
In the end, ill leave this here:
For you is your religion, and for me is my religion. (Quran 109-6)
2 Likes
Bruh, you made the mistake of typing this about an Abrahamic religion. What? A religion founded in the 7th century might need some touch ups and isn’t going to be relevant all throughout time? An idea practically unheard of to some people.
[quote=““Sheeda Pistol””]
Dude, you on a Muslim site telling majority Muslims here that Hinduism philosophy is superior to Abrahamic religions?
Carry on
[/quote]
Here is what I wrote.
“If you put it that way, I am comparing human made religions, period. Muslims worship a black stone in Mecca, if you want to go there!
And yes, Hinduism philosophy, to me, is superior to the fear that dominates Abrahamic religion.”
It is astounding how some people think! Just because there are majority Muslims here, how is stating that TO ME, Hinduism philosophy is better is somehow outrageous or worse? What exactly are you suggesting, “dude”? That someone should not express themselves re how they feel about Hinduism philosophy vs Islam? Just because the majority are Muslims? Do you even hear yourself? Maybe, just maybe, some of the criticism against those who cannot see past their religion is warranted.
As for the black stone line, it was in response to someone else mocking idol worship. So shut your pie hole. Or not, “dude”
[quote=““Sheeda Pistol””]
I am not going to take an applogetic stand to whatever humming bird said. He/She can debate that with you.
You on the other hand, being a Hindu said that Islam needs reform and also that Hinduism philosophy is superior to Abrahamic religions. And Yes, being a Muslim, I will point this out every time someone says it.
Remember that you are on a Muslim majority forum, so do not come here to mock, belittle Islam or detail a thread.
In the end, ill leave this here:
For you is your religion, and for me is my religion. (Quran 109-6)
[/quote]
Re your first sentence, context matters. If you are not going to state your opinion re humming birds mocking of Hinduism, then stay out of it! You can’t have it both ways, “dude”
Also, you have selectively stated my position. Let me correct that for you. I stated ALL religions need reform. Including Hinduism. Not just Islam? HOw is that belittling Islam? It is stating the truth.
And why is my statement that to me Hinduism philosophy is better than Ismal so offensive to you?
Re the quote from Quran, it is a good one. Maybe you ought to practice it. Which means be objective. Or else do not get involved in a debate between two members.
And I will leave it here, “dude”
Careful, you might offend some “dude”
[quote=““Sheeda Pistol””]
I am not going to take an applogetic stand to whatever humming bird said. He/She can debate that with you.
You on the other hand, being a Hindu said that Islam needs reform and also that Hinduism philosophy is superior to Abrahamic religions. And Yes, being a Muslim, I will point this out every time someone says it.
Remember that you are on a Muslim majority forum, so do not come here to mock, belittle Islam or detail a thread.
In the end, ill leave this here:
For you is your religion, and for me is my religion. (Quran 109-6)
[/quote]
Your concern regarding this thread being derailed is duly noted. If you must know why this thread got derailed, look no further than diwana reply to you in post 19 of this thread where he stated
“Erdogan is a thorn in the eyes of his opponents especially** Hindu Fanatics and supporters of Modi the terrorist** on this site, but he did what is right.”
Whi exactly are the Hindus fanatics on THIS site that he is referring to? I am the only Hindu who visits this site regularly. And surely, a person who states Hinduism and Islam need reform is not a Hindu fanatic!
So yes, he was trolling. He is responsible for the derailing of this thread.
But of course, you wouldn’t see it that way, would you, “dude”?
[quote=““humming bird””]
Lost the argument so start talking about my parents? OK!
Do you do everything what your parents taught you?
Do you do everything what your religion taught you?
Answer both in yes then i’ll give you my answer.
And btw clearly liar liar pants on fire, you said you care less? You spent rest of the three posts I just read only talking about my post. Thats what you call caring less? OK!
[/quote]
Why even talk to a rabid hateful dog?
Oh no…
He will be made a moderator “again” now that I talked ill of it.
Remember Phonexdesi?
[quote=““Sheeda Pistol””]
I am not going to take an applogetic stand to whatever humming bird said. He/She can debate that with you.
You on the other hand, being a Hindu said that Islam needs reform and also that Hinduism philosophy is superior to Abrahamic religions. And Yes, being a Muslim, I will point this out every time someone says it.
Remember that you are on a Muslim majority forum, so do not come here to mock, belittle Islam or detail a thread.
In the end, ill leave this here:
For you is your religion, and for me is my religion. (Quran 109-6)
[/quote]
While you are right.
There was no need to cater the moron.
Yeah but someone had to.
He quoted my same post twice in two different replies, I must have ht a nerve or two 
[quote=““Sheeda Pistol””]
Yeah but someone had to.
He quoted my same post twice in two different replies, I must have ht a nerve or two
[/quote]
Understood.
This is “special kind” of moron. Will flip flop.
Will apologize. Will say shame on you.
But,
Will come back with more of, at times defensive, then aggressive, offensive and deliberately inciting posts.
After a long time people should understand his true nature.
TLK somehow nurtured him if you know what I mean.
Nasty people who feel the need to say horrible things about our Prophet (Peace be upon him) are not any better than Muslims going around and killing these people. If you denounce these murderers (I do too) you should he rqually against people who want to play the drvil and insult our Prophet (peace be upon him).
I suggest you read the biography of Muhammad (peace be upon him), you will read how his enemies slandered, mistreated him and he didn’t kill them. He forgave. Those claiming to be ashiq-e-Rasool but think it’s okay to celebrate murders are not following his teachings. Islam is clear, muslims are missguided. Hence why blaming Islam for these issues is useless.
Really? Come on. So biased.
Muslims do not consider their religion to be man made so therefore your comparison won’t mean much to muslims.
As I said before, Islam does not contradict itself. How can you claim muslims worship the black stone when Islam forbids idolatry?! Again, flawed comparison.
I think it’s fine if you feel Hinduism is superior to Islam. I am not offended, and I think noone on this forum should either. Everyone is free to choose his religion, there’s no compulsion in Islam. I myself believe Islam is superior to any other religion, obviously. But what I won’t do is telling others they need to take a stand against their holy book and reform their religion so that it is deemed acceptable by those who don’t even follow the religion. Islam will not be a watered down version like other religions. Outsiders won’t understand.
I do not agree with people refering to any religion as garbage, that’s not needed at all. You may disagree with the religion, but can remain respectful.
Also, Islam forbids idolatry. Period. Why you’re so offended by this? It doesn’t forbid you or other Hindus from worshipping idols? I am not affected by those who believe that God doesn’t exist. I disagree with their claim but it doesn’t stop me from believing in God and in the the Oneness of God or the way I believe in God.
2 Likes
What kinda touch ups tho?
This was a completely gratuitous & senseless move by Erdogan... again. Well since 2011 onwards his tally of such fatuous gambits and preposterous measures have backfired big time. One just needs to look at his AKP's recent election standings and TL's continuous crumbling value, among other fiascos to understand why he is losing so many admirers.
My post was in response to humming bird, who essentially attacked Hinduism. You may want to go upthread for context. It does not apply to Muslims who do not insult other religions. I personally do not compare religions.
I have already clarified my comments re Quran with you earlier. So I am not going to revisit it here.
I didn’t refer to any religion as garbage.
Impersonaliy do not care who worships idols or who doesn’t. My comments re idol worship were meant for humming bird alone.
My comment re preferring Hinduism philosophy, which I do, was also in response to humming bird. I got no beef with you and other good people here. And I believed I have clarified that earlier in another thread to you directly
Every religion needs touch ups. Including Islam! I get it that some feel their religion is perfect. I just respectfully disagree,
Nit sure why some (may not be you) get so sensitive re reform. All of us need reform in the sense we all can improve, why not religions?
Why do some Muslims take the sentence all religions need reform as an insult to Islam? I certainly won’t get offended if someone says Hinduism needs reform.
To put this in context, folks here have stated all Hindus are bad, and have abused Ram. Why? Because they got oh so offended when confronted with “all religions need reform”.
Seriously though, if this is what modern day Islam is teaching its followers, how can anyone make the case for Islam not needing reform.
I certainly cannot make the case Hinduism does not need reform!
Anyway, I am out for now.