i am not here to complain about anyone. I just wanted to ask that since the topic relating to Ahmadiyya movement is not allowed for now, as per the religion section rules…does it mean members of Ahmadiyya movement here no longer should post their opinion regarding other topics relating to Islam ?
Why is it that when ever i post or defend Islam in any thread in religion forum, people come up by saying that whatever i have been saying is the belief of my jamaat and they start accusing/questioning Ahmadiyyat. However, they do not quote my posts and explain where in my post have i said anything that is not in accordance to Islam. ( i have no problem discussing Ahmadiyyat and explain them their own beliefs but its not allowed for now, hence this post of mine )
Why is this behavior acceptable by other members? Please tell me if I should just read the threads and have no right to post my opinion about the topics relating to Islam. If I am this hated, why not just block my username in the religion section ? Though, if this behavior is not acceptable, i urge the moderators of religion forum to be a little more active and see how other members are treating their fellow Ahmadi Muslim guppies here.
Re: Treatment of some GS members for Ahmadis here.
I understand what you are saying and no, you have every right to participate in any thread and if you find out that someone is attacking you for no reason, please add the link in this thread.
Re: Treatment of some GS members for Ahmadis here.
thank you brother TLK. No, i will not add a link of anyone attacking me. It's all good. I was thinking of just keeping quiet from now on. There is no such thing as respect here despite whichsoever belief one belongs to. We are far from having tolerance. I will continue to post in religion section(thanks for ur confirmation), however, if some members keep doing what they're doing, i will just quit posting. This will be all from me.
thank you brother TLK. No, i will not add a link of anyone attacking me. It's all good. I was thinking of just keeping quiet from now on. There is no such thing as respect here despite whichsoever belief one belongs to. We are far from having tolerance. I will continue to post in religion section(thanks for ur confirmation), however, if some members keep doing what they're doing, i will just quit posting. This will be all from me.
you be a bigger person, man. I've seen you ignoring some comments. Keep that up. Many people admire you for that.
Discussing religion on GS is of no use. The sooner u get it the sooner u'll stop wasting ur time trying to get ur point across. I know I did.
I so agree!! It hurts to read and are impulse to reply to different topics... but when a major population have a fixed set of mind.... then there is no use of giving/wasting your povs or opinions.
We are thought to pray.... Pray for the guidance for all (including ourselves) so keep doing that. Leave everything to Allah. thats what I have done and dont go to Religion section at all! not even to read wat is said that. .... coz it hurts!!
^ exactly. It hurts. Thats the reason why i don’t go there. It hurts even when I see eejits referring to Hazrat Mohammad saw as simply Muhammad. They can’t even be bothered putting something like pbuh infront of the name. There is no sharm-o-haya among some people there. And if I was to mention this to them in the thread, even in the most politest manner, if I was to request them to take Hazrat Mohammad saw’s name with some manners, I would be laughed at and perhaps even be labelled an extremist.
I understand what you are saying and no, you have every right to participate in any thread and if you find out that someone is attacking you for no reason, please add the link in this thread.
you be a bigger person, man. I've seen you ignoring some comments. Keep that up. Many people admire you for that.
thanks bud. I do apologize for bringing up this issue, take it as my frustration or my intolerance. I had to ask for the confirmation that i am actually allowed to post.
barbiedoll, thanks for ur concern. Yes, at times, i feel very frustrated to keep tellin the same person about the same old thing over and over. I do sometimes feel that they shud just bring all the arguments forward so i know exactly what to reply, but the sarcastic way of makin fun of someone is something i still have to know how to tolerate. But ya, it is sometimes a good idea to take a break from religion section. People there know only one thing, that is to bring down the one they're talking to. ( im included in that too somtimes ).
Re: Treatment of some GS members for Ahmadis here.
Mr Popat,
do you realise that Ahmadiyya beliefs are kuffar? Ahmadis do not consider Hz Mohammad (saw) as the last prophet.
have you read the false and offensive things Ghulam Ahmad has written in his books? For Ahmadis considering him a prophet is a pre-requisite of their faith. how then can they call Ahmadiyyat Islam?
Ahmdiyyat is not Islam.
In fact Ahmadiyyat Contradicts Islam.
*let go of your wrong Ahmadi beliefs and embrace true Islam. *
stop behaving like you are being insulted if someone says anything negative about ahmadiyyat or mirza ghulam. the man had evil intentions or was mentally not fit. this is a fact not an insult.
if you come and start praising the man who has said unacceptable things about Islam and perpetrating his agenda and teachings, of course people will negate you. stop portraying that as insulting please.
surely we are to respect other religions as Muslims, but if we are supposed to respect the person who said wrong things about Islam and professed to be a prophet, it is difficult. surely we have the right to point out that he was untrue and said false things (and i am using very mild words here). if you feel this is an insult you are the one who needs to accept the facts.
i appeal to the moderators and admin to stop this silent approval of ahmadiyyat. we need to spell the truth loud and clear. Ahmadiyyat is Kufr. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was an untrue person.
Re: Treatment of some GS members for Ahmadis here.
TLK sir,
i was also like you - trying to give Ahmadis the "benefit of the doubt", trying to be "tolerant", and "nice"
but there is a thin line between being tolerant and allowing that which is wrong
Ahmadis are always perpetrating their agenda so their numbers can grow
as Muslims it is our duty to quell these efforts and pronouce the truth clearly - surely we can be nice to Ahmadis but that doesn't mean we allow them to wrongly portray our religion
Re: Treatment of some GS members for Ahmadis here.
^ Thanks for your input questioner. To avoid any confusion on anyone's part that GS is helping any specific religious school of thought or discouraging any other, we put a ban on the topic of Ahmediyat.
Re: Treatment of some GS members for Ahmadis here.
TLK,
by putting a ban on Ahmadiyat topic on this forum, you are actually harming Islam - because as Muslims it is our duty to point out clearly and educate widely how wrong it is.
sure you want to be fair to all faiths... but are you saying that Ahmadiyat is a faith?
Ahmadiyat is not a faith, it is a FITNAH, and it is specially designed to cause harm to Islam and the Ummah...
so, by putting a ban on Ahmadiyat, you are actually being biased, against Islam... as you are not allowing us to talk about one of the biggest Fitnah of Islam...
(i know this ibias/harm is unintentional or implicit, but this is how it is...)
therefore, please release the ban and allow open discussion so that as they say in Urdu "doodh ka doodh aur pani ka pani ho jae" for all readers of forum. i myself have learnt a thing or two in fact more thru threads on this forum on Ahmadiyat
have fun!
Hazrat Isa banney ka mshwara kion de rahy hu becharey ko:wink:
