Re: Top 10 reasons why Muslim men dont keep beards
does hadeeth make something farz? or is that the domain of Allah to make something farz? There is a huge difference in my view regarding the prophet explaining something that is already commanded in Quran, because then there is no doubt, while ppl may disagree on the exact approach i.e. the difference in exactly how to pray salat..but ppl know that salat is commanded and that the prophet in his actions showed different ways of doing it.
When you see something that is not in the Quran, and just attributed to hadeeth, then not only do you have questions about whether it is authentic, but also how important is it, because if it was so important that your faith would be incomplete without it would Allah not have noted that in Quran.
This is also not a question of rejecting hadeeth, but a question of asking whather a hadeeth has the power to make something farz, i.e. a must do something without which your faith is incomplete.