I read this in Urdu and decided to translate for the benifit of people who cannot read Urdu.
One non beliver asked a Muslim scholar these three questions and said if you can answer them I will convert.
If everything happens with the will of Allah then how can you blame a human for any misgivings ?
If Shaitan is made of fire how can hell fire hurt him ?
When you cannot see Allah how can you believe in him ?
In reply this scholar picked up a clump of dirt and hit that guy with it.
The guy got mad and sued the scholar in the Qazi court.
Qazi summoned the scholar to the court and asked:
Why did you hit this guy instead of answering his genuine questions?
The scholar said:
The answer to the first question is . If I hit him with the will of Allah then why he is suing me ?
The second answer is that humans have been created from dirt then how can a clump of dirt hurt him.
The answer to the third question is if he cannot see the pain cause by this clump of dirt then how can he feel it ?
The non believer converted on the spot.
I read this in Urdu and decided to translate for the benifit of people who cannot read Urdu.
One non beliver asked a Muslim scholar these three questions and said if you can answer them I will convert.
1. If everything happens with the will of Allah then how can you blame a human for any misgivings ?
2. If Shaitan is made of fire how can hell fire hurt him ?
3. When you cannot see Allah how can you believe in him ?
In reply this scholar picked up a clump of dirt and hit that guy with it.
The guy got mad and sued the scholar in the Qazi court.
Qazi summoned the scholar to the court and asked:
Why did you hit this guy instead of answering his genuine questions?
The scholar said:
The answer to the first question is . If I hit him with the will of Allah then why he is suing me ?
The second answer is that humans have been created from dirt then how can a clump of dirt hurt him.
The answer to the third question is if he cannot see the pain cause by this clump of dirt then how can he feel it ?
The non believer converted on the spot.
who was that non beliver ? very curious .. i have business proposition for him.
Brother Mirch: It’s a rare case, and majority of “non-believers” will not convert because of three logically answered mystical questions, in today’s times.
Here is my response, but it may not jive on this forum
1) God's Will is reflected in the system, in the universe, in us, while he has given us a choice and let us "loose" to choose our individual and collective destiny. His system is clear in that if we do good, sooner or later we are rewarded; if we do bad, sooner or later it comes back to haunt us. By becoming "Muslim", you are SUBMITTING to the system, thereby submitting to God's Will (recognizing the cold hard reality that you are responsible for your deeds and your actions are judged by the system that has been setup) and thereby being at PEACE. Eeman is reflected in you being at peace, thereby being in HARMONY with your surroundings.
2) SHAITAN ==> from ShTN (distant/detached-from-reality/long-rope/serpant-like) - which is also a djinn ==> JNN (veiled/hidden/that-which-you-cannot-see/which-has-you-blinded) - which is also malikah ==> MLK (that which can control) - which is Iblees (BLS: which-causes-dispair/grief)
As we can see, "made of fire" is allegorical for chaos, burning, negative etc etc... we all have a "shaitan" in us, which we cannot see, hence djinn, and that which can control us, hence malikah, which takes us away from reality and everything good, hence shaitan, and that which ultimately causes grief/dispair/suffering, hence iblees.
3) Please prove it categorically that God does not exist.
I forgot to mention that this dialogue (if you can call it that) looks to me like a fabrication. Woe to whoever envisioned it for it shows one's arrogance, and not God's Will.
conversion is great sin which no god or religion will forgive
But reversion is not. Unless you (in general) are a believer of the Theory of Evolution, then you believe and know that we're all offsprings of Adam and Eve, who according to muslim beliefs were Muslims as revealed by the Holy Quran. So when a non-muslim chooses to become a muslim/muslimah, he or she is basically reverting back to Islam. Although it's termed conversion.
In order to believe that, you first have to believe that 1. we are offsprings of Adam and Eve and 2. that there exists one supreme Creator of this world and all that lies beyond this universe and 3. Have the know-about of the history of Religion (as a whole).
You, then will be able to see, how the mankind developed into different tribes, races, cultures, religions and branched off. Islam in name, came about way after Christianity and Judaism, and that is because it leads back to the straight path/the original path, before people diverted from the true religion of God.
This is my belief, and the belief of majority of muslims.
today is load better than Prophet Muhammad PBUH’s time
this is nothing…just imagine if someone is coming to kill you (i know many of us can freak out…even just imagine this can shivers you), but after hears your recitation of Quran convert’s to Muslims, then you or they themself dont require any rationality.
these stories are usually made by people of faith to show how true their faith is. muslims, christians, hindus...all make them. in some cases they are so childish that only a faithful is led to believe it. most of them times the characters are obscure( because it never happened in the first place) or very famous ones( if einstein believed in God, who the heck are you not to believe in him). further there is no proof of it. and no historical evidence either.
:)…Just the otherday I witnessed this gora young man in his teens not quite 20 revert to Islam…and from his looks.he was very happy…he came from a christian family…and felt confident that he was forgiven…you cant beat that..Lakkis! :k:
When i was young I thought that i will be a superstar in movies,will earn millions and every single girl on planet will be ready to marry me. Can you beat that sindsagar:snooty:.
But reversion is not. Unless you (in general) are a believer of the Theory of Evolution, then you believe and know that we're all offsprings of Adam and Eve, who according to muslim beliefs were Muslims as revealed by the Holy Quran. So when a non-muslim chooses to become a muslim/muslimah, he or she is basically reverting back to Islam. Although it's termed conversion.
In order to believe that, you first have to believe that 1. we are offsprings of Adam and Eve and 2. that there exists one supreme Creator of this world and all that lies beyond this universe and 3. Have the know-about of the history of Religion (as a whole).
You, then will be able to see, how the mankind developed into different tribes, races, cultures, religions and branched off. Islam in name, came about way after Christianity and Judaism, and that is because it leads back to the straight path/the original path, before people diverted from the true religion of God.
This is my belief, and the belief of majority of muslims.
I appreciate your nice and meaningful explanation, instead of bashing other religions like some of the guppies do.. you explained it in better words
just check the bolded words..
when you say Allah is the god i believe it, but i don't believe in religion
I appreciate your nice and meaningful explanation, instead of bashing other religions like some of the guppies do.. you explained it in better words
just check the bolded words..
when you say Allah is the god i believe it, but i don't believe in religion
this is just my belief
My pleasure bro. And you are fully entitled to your beliefs, and are worthy of respect for whatever it is that you believe. The message of Islam is to basically deliver the message of goodtidings and warn and remind people of the calamities that fell on ancient nations before us and our time. When the message has been delivered, the rest is up to an individual. One will reap the fruits of their own deeds.
Who knows where i'll end up, but i constantly ask for forgiveness and guidance myself. :)
