Thread splitted from 'Muslim anymore' to Example of Shirk

[khoji]

Re: Thread splitted from ‘Muslim anymore’ to Example of Shirk

Why don’t you just admit that this hadith is fake?

@The_Jinx

Point is that Quran can not be “corrected” (read amended) by anyone even the prophet (saw) because these are not words of human but words of the God Himself.

Ever heard of “mansookh” verses of Quran?
Prophet can’t correct it but God can and God did. If there is confusion due to saying “By Teen” then God should have corrected it later … just like prophet did.

It’s God who swears by Teen, Zaitoon, Toor, Quran etc. so the question of shirk is ridiculous in these examples.

If God can do it then so can people, otherwise God would have said clearly.

If it is ridiculous in these examples only because God says so then it should also be ridiculous in the other example because prophet said so. Prophet did not say anything without God’s approval.