Thread splitted from 'Muslim anymore' to Example of Shirk

[Surdar_Asif]

Re: Thread splitted from ‘Muslim anymore’ to Example of Shirk

@psyah

It is reported on the authority of Qatelah (ra) that a Jewish man came to the Prophet [SAW] and said to him: "Verily, you (Muslims) commit *Shirk, for you say: “As Allah Wills and as you will;” and you say: “By the *Ka’abah!” And so the Prophet [SAW] ordered whoever wanted to swear, to say: “By the Rabb of theKa’abah!” and to say: “As Allah Wills, then as you will.” (Narrated by An-Nasaa`i, who said that it is authentic)

---

Just wondering if the narrator of this hadith is Qutelah binte Qais? she was the controversial woman who married Rasool Allah but apostated after his death. Sure it sounds absurd that Rasool Allah who was sent for the purpose of teaching and propagating the message of tauheed will need to be corrected by a Jew in something as fundamental as this.