protest were not against hindus…
those were against government and system…and muslim did not target hindus but targeted peoples from north east…
though i dont like and support such revenge attacks on innocent peoples from any ethnicity and religion but thats what all we do right…
price for the act of muslims from godhra was paid by muslims from all over gujrat right…?
price for killing of indira was paid by sikhs of delhi right?
As far as tamil and srilankan relations are concerned…those tamil living in srilanka are not citizens of india right?
Didn't the BJP protest turn violent yesterday over some lame land issue or something? Why couldn't they have carried out the protest peacefully when the issue at hand was nowhere near as serious as a massacre? They too injured their own people and police personnel so why isn't the majority population questioning their patriotism?
It's pathetic but when do protests in Pakistan and India not turn violent? That's why I said in my first post that our desi awaam loves revenge and loves to take matters into their own hands, that has nothing to do with their religion, unlike what Dronacharya seems to be taunting about.
Everything about this particular case is very much about religion. Muslims in the rest of India are threatening fellow Indians from the North-east in the rest of India because tribals and illegal muslim Bangladesh settlers killed each other. So Indian muslims are threatening NE Indians to leave that part of India before Ramzan and such stuff. Already some tibetians who atleast have a legitimate reason to be in India were beaten up because they looked like NE Indians. The result is mass exodus and fear which we see. Just who is going to stand up for the tribals who also lost their lives at the hands of illegal muslim Bangla settlers ? The rest of India ? What will be the result of this ? More communal violence where muslims will be the losers.
^ Instead of crying about illegal Bangladeshis, why doesnt India improve its border security? Besides most of these were happily taken over by India before the 1971 war. So whats the problem now?
You make it sound like those protesting Muslims are not actually Indians. Say what? They’re not immigrants, they’re native Indians. They’re as much Indians as any hindu or sikh or atheist. When Hindus in Pakistan speak up against persecution, are they being anti-national too or are they simply protesting for the right cause? You’re basically saying that if Pakistani Ahmadis condemn an attack on the Ahmadi community that they’re going against the rest of Pakistan and that gives everyone the reason to doubt their patriotism. Yeh kahan ka logic hai mere bhai?*
However U justify it , muslims have no business rioting for illegal immigrants against rest of India. They have no right asking Indian NE people to leave any part of India. What they can co is ask their illegal brethren to leave India peacefully if they want to be involved. Why aren’t they protesting against Bangla immigrants ? Like I said before Tamil problem is localized to Tamil Nadu and Sri Lanka . It did not spread all over India either against Buddhists or Lankans. Do you have incidents of the rest of India protesting against Buddhists ? Open a seperate thread if U want to discuss Tamil problem. IMO the Assam problem must have been contained to the state instead it has taken a communal hue and spread all over. Answer this why isn’t Bangladesh protesting instead after all its citizens were involved ?
The violence in Assam was a result of clashes between Bodos and “resident Muslims” and not Bangladeshi immigrants, the National Commission for Minorities has said while recommending setting up of an SIT to probe major incidents of violence in the state.
The NCM delegation, which included Planning Commission member Syeda Hameed and NCM member K.N. Daruwalla, visited Kokrajhar, Gossaigaon, Dhubri and Bilasipara in July. Its report said the cause of the riot originated from the conflict between the Bodos and the resident Muslims of BTAD, and not between Bangladeshi migrants and the Bodos, even though it said infiltration from Bangladesh did take place throughout the year.
“The conflict this time as far as we could see was not between some exodus of Bangladeshi immigrants and the Bodos but between the Bodos and the resident Muslims of the BTAD.”
Minority Commission is controlled by Congress Party which is responsible for settling these illegals in India in order to create their “vote bank” in Assam.
You make it sound like those protesting Muslims are not actually Indians. Say what? They're not immigrants, they're native Indians. They're as much Indians as any hindu or sikh or atheist. When Hindus in Pakistan speak up against persecution, are they being anti-national too or are they simply protesting for the right cause? You're basically saying that if Pakistani Ahmadis condemn an attack on the Ahmadi community that they're going against the rest of Pakistan and that gives everyone the reason to doubt their patriotism. Yeh kahan ka logic hai mere bhai?
The problem is Muslims are protesting against other Indians for illegal immigrants . Why are they not just protesting loss of life ? Why are they not protesting the massacre of tribals by the illegal immigrants ? Protesting against loss of life is the right thing to do but not if the protest is in support of one group of people (who had no business being there) only because they share the same religion. I condem any loss of life and hope the Govt can reach a solution and the illegal immigrants can be deported without any loss of life. Atrocities were committed by both tribals and illegal muslims and I stand with my fellow citizens irrespective of religion for a peaceful solution and not for the intimidation of my brothers and sisters.
Why hindus not protesting against loss of life on both sides.........:D
Maybe Hindus were minding their business and waiting for Govt to act. Now maybe they will protest against muslims who were protesting against Indians :D
Indian Muslims have full right to protest against the "massacre" of illegal Bangladeshis Total number of illegals+Bodos killed is about 75]in Assam. Why they don't protest for more education and job opportunities for themselves is beyond me. They also have full right to protest against "pogrom" of Muslims in Mynamar , even though hundreds of thousand Indian farmers commit suicide and thousands of Indian kids die becuase of starvation every year. But why no protest for the poor Muslims of Pakistan, Syria, Behrain, as well as rest of the "Muslim World" where the ummah is oppressed by despots and monarchs is beyond my understanding. Are they not human beings ? Are they sub-human ?
Maybe Hindus were minding their business and waiting for Govt to act. Now maybe they will protest against muslims who were protesting against Indians :D
In July 2012 the Indian state of Assam saw outbreaks of violence between indigenous Bodos and BangladeshiMuslim immigrants. Lok Sabha member from Bodoland Sansuma Khunggur Bwiswmuthiary blamed illegal immigration for the violence in the state.[SUP][12]](2012 Assam violence - Wikipedia)[/SUP] Public intellectuals in Assam have stressed the increase of Muslim population has been disproportionate. The Election Commissioner, H.S. Brahma, said the details of the 2011 census reveal that 11 of the 27 districts of Assam now have a Muslim majority due to illegal immigration from Bangladesh.[SUP][13]](2012 Assam violence - Wikipedia)[/SUP][SUP][2]](2012 Assam violence - Wikipedia)[/SUP] Prime Minister Manmohan Singh was criticised for not dealing with the flood of illegal immigrants from Bangladesh. He was accused of not taking preventive action against illegal immigrants who are usurping native lands of Bodos.Increasing Muslim population consists of refugees from the erstwhile East Pakistan prior to the 1971 Indo-Pakistani War[SUP][15]](2012 Assam violence - Wikipedia)[/SUP] and subsequent migrants from Bangladesh who are illegal in the region.
U can bold the complete sentence and take the full thing into context instead of partial responses and trying to change the meaning . Rather underhanded of you :)
Don’t put words in my mouth. Where have I said that Muslims are terrorists ?
You can’t compare act of an individual with that of a community. A brave Hindu might have slapped, doesn’t imply that the Hindu community is not oppressed in Pakistan. OTOH, the pictures that I have posted do imply that Muslims are not “oppressed” in India as you are constantly whining in this forum. Those in the mob are having a great time, with wide smiles on their faces. Has there ever been a Hindu mob in Pakistan ? No ? I guess everything must be hunky dory there
[QUOTE]
every year lot of protests are conducted by majority where public property and police vehicles are damaged but when ever muslims do that it has some link to terrorism...
[/QUOTE]
So Muslims should commit *shirk *just because non-Muslims do it. Didn't expect such an argument from an ultra pious *momin *like you. But I don't have any problem with Muslim mobs going on rampage.
BTW, do you think desecration of amar jawan jyoti, molestation of female constables, and idol breaking of Lord Mahavira and Lord Buddha are also legitimate forms of protest for the Muslims ?
Don't put words in my mouth. Where have I said that Muslims are terrorists ?
You can't compare act of an individual with that of a community. A brave Hindu might have slapped, doesn't imply that the Hindu community is not oppressed in Pakistan. OTOH, the pictures that I have posted do imply that Muslims are not "oppressed" in India as you are constantly whining in this forum. Those in the mob are having a great time, with wide smiles on their faces.
Was my post about linking terrorism with muslim directe at you? i dont think so
I never said that every indian muslim is oppressed but that does not mean no discrimination takes place against muslims in india :D
What about the link to news about killing of 4 persons from north east in banglore?
Don't put words in my mouth. Where have I said that Muslims are terrorists ?
You can't compare act of an individual with that of a community. A brave Hindu might have slapped, doesn't imply that the Hindu community is not oppressed in Pakistan. OTOH, the pictures that I have posted do imply that Muslims are not "oppressed" in India as you are constantly whining in this forum. Those in the mob are having a great time, with wide smiles on their faces. Has there ever been a Hindu mob in Pakistan ? No ? I guess everything must be hunky dory there
Why not give example of us now.....when you think of pakistan as failed nation....:D
Jab dil chaha US ka example jab dil chaha pakistan ka Subhan allah