Things that (should) make u go hmmmmm

[Lajawab]

Re: Things that (should) make u go hmmmmm

@Curious One

Ok so now you change your stance that its not about sunnah of other prophets where as in your earlier posts you stated

So you don’t come right out and admit it but atleast you drop that stance.

NOw it basically boils down to Hz Abu Bakr’s words against those of Bibi Fatima.

Shall we look at what were the statements made by the two parties
He claims that prophet told him that Rasools do not leave inheritance where as I proved from quran that they do. So now you are claiming quran is more imp then hadeeth but at the same time your whole argument is based on a hadith that goes against quran.

Brother I don’t mean to insult anyone’s belief or hurt anyone’s feelings but please just step back for a bit and thnk about it, the quran proves that prophets do leave inheritance for their family where as the hadith that Hz Abu Bakar used to refute Bibi Fatima’s claim says they don’t, which of the two would you prefer to follow.

I know its extremely difficult but forget about the parties involved and think for a second that Hz Abu Bakar is not infallibe so maybe he was mistaken specially since the hadith he is quoting is contradicting Quran.

1. The fact about the Prophets (pbut) not leaving any inheritance are not my words…They are the words of the Holy Prophet :saw:, hence that would mean it is a Sunnah of all the Prophets (pbut)…

2. As far as leaving inheritance is concerned, who cares if Sulaiman or Daud :as: received or did not receive inheritance…Do you follow their Sunnah? And the books you quote are Shia books and I don’t accept their validity…Sorry…

3. Sulaiman (as) is mentioned as a heir of Daud (as)…In what? I Dirhams and Dinars and horses? No…He is a heir in prohethood as Yusuf (as) was to Yaqub (as)…

Here’s another Hadith…

**“Scholars are the heirs of prophets, and prophets neither left behind dinars nor dirhams (Arab coins); rather they left knowledge. He who acquires knowledge has really gained something of great value.” **

This is from Hadith…

From the Quran:

Surah Maryam:**
4 Saying: "My Lord! Indeed my bones have grown feeble, and grey hair has spread on my head, And I have never been unblest in my invocation to You, O my Lord!
5 "And Verily! I fear my relatives after me, since my wife is barren. So give me from Yourself an heir,
6 “Who shall inherit me, and inherit (also) the posterity of Yaqoob (Jacob) (inheritance of the religious knowledge and Prophethood, not the wealth, etc.). And make him, my Lord, one with whom You are Well-pleased!”.
7 (Allah said) “O Zakariya (Zachariah)! Verily, We give you the glad tidings of a son, His name will be Yahya (John). We have given that name to none before (him).”**

Does this mean that inheriting from the posterity of Yaqub :as: means inheriting wealth? Is that what you think?

---

And while searching for your answer, I came across this:

http://experts.about.com/q/947/3261143.htm

Inetersting to say the least…Perhaps you can first refute what’s in these books of yours before you bring your books as proofs…

(For some reason you have to click the link a couple of times…)