Re: Things that (should) make u go hmmmmm
If you forget about the most important part which is that she did deserve and had rights to it you are claiming that Hz Abu Bakr would be
But if you realize that it was her right then by giving her the charity he would have
-
Obeyed Allah (swt)…
-
Obeyed the Messenger (saw)
-
Upheld the Sunnah of the Prophets (pbut)
-
Upheld the teachings of Islam…
-
Upheld the rights of those to whom that charity belonged…
-
Secured the Amanahof the Ummah…
-
Set an example of obyeing Allah (swt) and the Messenger (saw)…etc…
Is this correct or not??
You also mentioned that it was against the sunnah of all the prophets to inheritance for their family members .
Allah (swt) declares in Surah Naml 027.016:
And Solomon was David’s heir. He said: “O ye people! We have been taught the speech of birds, and on us has been bestowed (a little) of all things: this is indeed Grace manifest (from Allah.)”
Al-Qur’an, Surah 27, Ayah 16, translated by Yusufali
Various books of Ahl-e-Sunnah proves that prophet Sulayman inherited his father’s worldy posession here is a list of few of the books
- Tafseer Khazan Volume 5 page 112, Surah Naml
- Tafseer Durre Manthur Volume 5 page 193 Surah Naml
- Tafseer Rul al Ma’ani Part 19Page 170 Surah Naml
- Tafseer Mazhari Part 16, Volume 7 page 100 Surah Naml
- Tafseer Muraghee Part 19 page 127 Surah Naml
- Tafseer Jauhar Volume 13 page 135 Surah Naml
- Tafseer Gharab al Qur’an Part 18 page 88
- Tafseer Kashaf Volume 3 page 140
- Tafseer Mu’allim al Tanzeel under the commentary of Khazan Volume 5 page 112
- Tafseer Fathooath al Ilayha Volume 3 page 202
- Al Bidayah wa al Nihaya Volume 5 page 290
- Tareekh Abu’l Fida Volume 1 page24
Do you want me to mention what it says in all this books or is the reference enough.
To David We gave Solomon (for a son),how excellent in Our service! Ever did he turn (to Us)!
Behold, there were brought before him, at eventide coursers of the highest breeding, and swift of foot;
Al-Qur’an, Surah Sa’d, Ayah 30 & 31, translated by Yusufali
These horses were inheritance, so it is proved beyong any doubt that prophets do leave inheritance for their family members, and these are the ayat’s Bibi Fatima quoted in her khutba in refuting Hz Abu Bakr’s claim that prophets do not leave any inheritance.
So now in light of all this you tell me is that Hadith (Propehts do not leave inheritance (used by Hz Abu Bakr to refute Bibi Fatima’s claim…)more important or the Quran?
If you think that the Hadith is more important and that Hz. Abu Bakr did the right thing by angering Bibi Fatima, then hmmm x infinite to your aqaaids…
If you think the Quran is more important, then you should know that Hz. Abu Bakr did the wrong thing as per the Quran.