Re: The Prophet only knows what Allah reveals to Him
ok no offence.
None taken.
So it sounds like U wanted Prophet s.a.w to make aircrafts and spaceships, to proof that he had knowledge ?
Unfotunately thats what some people were suggesting that prophet had knowledge more than all of us. If the person was talking about wisdom I would agree with him but knowledge and wisdom are two different things.
at how many occasions Imam Ali asked people that ask me what you want to ask.
By any chance are you suggesting that Ali was as wise as the prophet?
Now if i know some calculus this doesnt mean am gona be teaching my 5th grader brother how to do calc. I mean i wud only discuss it with somone who has some idea. and 1400 years ago i dunt think even the word technology existed. i hope u get the point.
Logic is really funny sometimes. Using the example above will it be safe to say that if I do not discuss rocket science with you (assumption on my part that you would not understand) will make me an expert rocket scientist?
Our technolgy yet cant explain how Prophet s.a.w broke moon into two peices, we simply call it miracle, the things that cant be explained how. i have heared from the begining that world is round while in hadees kisa it says, "aur zameen ko jo bichai gai" and finally abt 3 yrs back theyme up with the theory that earth isnt round after all. Rasool s.a.w stopped us from eating haram, even though he cud have explained y things are haram who cud have followed what he was talkin abt ?
I could not see your point bringing in the miracles into the discussion. Knowledge, wisdom and miracles are three different topics.