The Not Moderate Muslim Thread

Not quite. You’ve got your history a little wrong. This line of the discussion started with you saying:

The subject is that those of you in the west tend to define yourselves in terms of “moderate Muslim” or “Liberal Muslim” when in actuality the faith is not changed.

Here there is a definite claim of statistical significance. ‘Tend to’ suggests that if you picked out a random person in the west they would define themselves in terms of ‘moderate muslim’. The proof you offer is 1/16 of ads in a single thread, a mix of people in the West and in Pakistan.

Which society exactly defines them merely as crazies?

Both judaism and christianity have their reform/progressive/liberal movements. I dont think we need to follow them in these respects but the impulse to appear ‘civilized’ and fit in with the modern world isnt limited to Muslims.

But beyond these fine points, I’ll come back to the point we were making earlier. You agreed with me that there is a definite distinction between people you prefer to call crazies and those who disavow what the ‘crazies’ stand for. Is what this distinction is referred to as really worth this much bile? Whether it be ‘crazies’/‘muslims’ or ‘extremists’/‘moderates’ or anything else might be an interesting academic discussion but really is linguistics that important to you?

Once again, you’re reading too much into words. ‘Moderate’ isnt so far removed from ‘Reformed’. A minority uses that exact label, and it possibly has currency partially because there is a direct translation to it into an Islamic concept (miana ravi).

I dont care to correct yours or anyone else’s definition of Muslim. Its a pointless, unprovable claim, and a black hole of fruitless back and forth.

My mentioning that there religious arguments for killing of civilians does not mean I regard those religious justifications as correct. I dont want to post links to their idiotic forums, but browse through this forum if you wish. There is no doubt that they do offer religious justifications for killing civilians/suicide bombing/other aspects of what people call ‘extremist’ and you call ‘crazies’

You and I dont comprise the Muslim world. We accept no justification to kill civilians, we accept no justification probably for a number of other things. Doesnt mean those justifications dont exist, and are regarded as Islamic by a certain number of Muslims. Just as you and I can call ourselves Muslims and others non-Muslims so can they to us. We can agree in this thread to call them non-Muslims, what do you think will happen? Will they and those who support them start calling them non-Muslims?

As a shia, I’ve seen my sunni coreligionists argue passionately about whether or not I was a Muslim. Does my religious state change because one side or the other gains ascendancy? Not really.

You can shout down other voices, but you cant think you’ll define their identity.