Re: The issue of Fadak
thats a whole another debate irrelevent to this discussion btw plz dont bring up zubair radiallahanu whenever talha is mentioned u guys think they were like hecke and jeckel thats not the case they both had very different backgrounds and interests
not so trivial some of them were very important matters I uthman had his own group of supporters in medina mostly quraishi but they could not stand upto the revolutionaries from Kufa and Egypt thats why uthmanid propoganda always lament uthman as the lonely martyr to hide the paucity of support amongst the medinians
neither hasan nor hussain ever bore arms to defend uthman at best they offered moral support
I do not know much about the early life of Talha and Zubayr to be honest but they both had very different endings from eachother. One realised the truth and the other did not.
Trivial is a word i used by mistake. I actually wanted to say IMPORTANT ISSUES.
And Tabari wrote about Hazrat Imam Hasan and Hazrat Imam Hussain along with Mohd b Hanafiya, Abbas Ibn Ali, Mohd bin Abi Bakr and other Bani Hashim coming to the aid of Uthman on the orders of Hazrat Imam Ali.