The issue of Fadak

Society Religion & Philosophy
45

Re: The issue of Fadak

Brother, I think you missed the whole point of the post above. There is a lot more to the issue of fadak than just a land. It unveils the faces of alot of personalities. Brother think about it Prophet P.B.U.H. on Allah SWT will gave a hadith on making Bibi Fatima Zehra SA angry makes Prophet P.B.U.H. angry and the other narration I quoted about Bibi Fatima Zehra SA getting angry on Hazrat Abu Bakar was also in Sahih Bukhrari and narrated by no other than the daughter of Hazrat Abu Bakar. Doesn’t the following serve as an eye opener for you:

  • Quran is asking to love Ahley bait
  • Prophet P.B.U.H. specifally mentioned whoever makes Bibi Fatima angry makes him angry Both were narrated in Sahih Bukhari…

Aren’t those indicatiosn for you who was righteous and who wasn’t?

When I quoted about Bibi Fatimia Zehra SA being angry on Abu Bakr I did not apply that she was angry soley because of the fadak incident… I can go on with a number of things but they are a whole new thing within it self. Just to quote a few… look into the following:

  1. Who did Prophet P.B.U.H. elected Mawla in his lifetime at the incident of Ghadir and who became khaleefa after his death… Having said that.. How did khaleefa overruled the ayats she presented over some hadith… Would you think the lady who was so pure that Prophet PBUH took her as the only lady during Mubahila she want present wrong ayats for a land nauzubillah… and yet Prophet P.B.U.H knowning her daughter nauzubillah can mis use quran and get angry for wrong reasons wiould say people making her angry would make Rasool e Khuda P.B.U.H. angry

  2. Where were some of the companions when the funeral of Prophet P.B.U.H took place… what was more important the funeral services of Prophet P.B.U.H. or the issue of Khilafat…

  3. How did Bibi Fatima Zehra S.A lost her son Hazrat Mohsin A.S…?

If you want to read on these incidents go to the following link for sunni refernces and details.

A Shi’ite Encyclopedia

If you want to listen something non shia, you can listen the following video

[

Brother I would nauzubillah refrain from making such a comment. Are you nazubillah implying your Aunty is more merciful that Bibi Fatima Zehra S.A. She is the daughter of Prophet P.B.U.H, I would rather use her actons to learn a lesson the lower the honor of a lady that Prophet P.B.U.H himself respected so much…](“http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...070561&q=ishaq”)