The issue of Fadak

[righteous]

Re: The issue of Fadak

@AllahkaBanda

then ask if you don’t understand before jumping to conclusions.

go read post#21](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/6456306-post21.html) to find out who you were talking to and what point you were addressing.

i made my point exactly the way i wanted to. you need to open your mind and heart to truth to understand.

incorrect; a sahabi is someone who accepted Islam, met/saw the Prophet (sal-allahu 'alayhi wa salam) and died as a believer.

This would not stand as a valid definition since you cannot establish whether someone die as a believer.

sahabi means a friend/companion. If you were a friend for someone, list 10 reasons that will make you run away in the other direction from their funeral.

stop beating around the bush. Why would Allah Ta’ala be pleased with munafiqoon or those who would become munafiq later? So, were there any munafiq among those who migrated from Medina to Makka or those who participated in battle of badr? Yes or No?

I think i m quite unequivocal about my point. I don’t know about badr or those who migrated but surely have a good idea about those who ran aay at Uhud.

why? This is the problem in your mind set, the obvious bias against the sahaba, which has led to hate for them. The obvious is that we pick those who are right in the sight of the Qur’an and Sunnah. We don’t pick because he is Ali or he is Abou Bakr (may Allah be pleased with them). We pick who is right according to the Qur’an and Sunnah. Now, don’t quote me ayaat by distorting their meaning to prove your flawed reasoning. If you want to disccus this further, open a new thread.

You know something, you don’t have a clue about what you are talking about.
You are supposed to draw conclusions based on facts not assumptions.

I don’t have bias against the sahaba and I do not hate them, but I refuse to take your argument for elevating them to the point of a deity or at least infallibility.

Please quote me where I have distorted the meaning of any ayaah. Whatever I have used ayahs in translation, they are 100% accurate and mostly taken from Ahle-sunnah translations.

This is a very big accusation that you have hurled on me regarding distorting Quran. May Allah have mercy on you and show you the right path.