You have no right to decide for them what they want. They decide. They choose. They get their basic democratic right.
End of discussion. And **** no to a federation. I will not even consider such a idea where another issue like Gujarat and its massacres can happen. Pakistan is damn fine without India. We don’t need India.
Now Kashmiris deserve their right to independence if it is there will. I am pretty damn certain they will opt for either Pakistan or independence. But the choice is theirs to make and nobody else.