The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

Of late I have seen a couple threads about atrocious ethnic cleansing. There seems to be an astounding shamelessness amongst some citizens of Pakistan about what has become of the Hindus in Pakistan. To set the record straight I am starting this thread. The following article I am quoting came up on a simple google of “population of Hindus in Pakistan in 1947”.

I don’t doubt that there will be accusations of the trustworthiness of this website and I have no way pf ascertaining that either. So if anyone disagreeing with the story and th enumbers are welcome to state their case and quote their sources too.

Here are some bottom line conclusions that if true ought to make every fairminded Pakistani apologize to their own Hindu citizens and make reparations:

  • Reduction of Hindu population from over 15% post partition (ie after removing the number that moved to India) to the current 2% or so

  • 1965 passage of something called “Enemy Property Act” designed to confiscate property of Hindus

  • Massacre and rape of Hindus during the 1970 and 1971 period by the Pakistani army

  • 1989 & 1992 - over 300 temples destroyed

  • Kidnapping of Hindu women and coercing them to convert to Islam

These are fromthisarticle.

There is a lack of awareness across the world about the very existence of a significant yet dwindling Hindu community in Pakistan. Presently it is estimated that Hindus make up 2% of Pakistan’s population. This is at least five times the number of Hindus in Britain. Before the end of colonial rule in 1947, the land that was to become Pakistan had a large proportion of Hindus, accounting for over 26% of the population. The Partition of India was the biggest forced migration of people in human history, and was accompanied by large scale massacres. During this period, the population of Hindus dropped to 15% in this region.
Even though there was heavy risk, many Hindus chose to remain in their ancestral homeland and were promised protection by the Government of Pakistan. However in practice, Hindus found it very difficult to live in Pakistan, where they were very vulnerable and often subject to persecution.
There was a constant level of crime and harassment against Hindus in Pakistan. The constitution and legal system that was framed for the new country openly discriminated against Hindus. During periods of tension between India and Pakistan, Hindus were killed and expelled in large numbers. In 1965 a law was passed that openly incited and legitimised confiscation of Hindu property. This was called “The Enemy Property Act”. Therefore the Hindu population steadily dropped.
During 1970 and 1971, huge massacres were perpetrated upon Hindus, by the Pakistani army. A proper study into the casualty figures has never been conducted. Estimates for the number dead are up to 3 million. Millions of Hindu women were raped and kidnapped in this period. It was one of the largest massacres in recent history, and also one of the most ignored.
In 1977, General Zia ul-Haq led a military coup in Pakistan. He introduced Islamic Law, which further excluded and marginalised Hindus.
In 1989 and 1992 over 300 Hindu temples were destroyed. Many Hindus lost their homes. The largest outward migration of Hindus from Pakistan since Partition took place during these years.
Unbelievable as it may seem, Hindus still exist in Pakistan, numbering over 2.5 million. The Hindu population is largest in the Sindh province, but there are Hindu communities dotted all over Pakistan. They suffer constant threats against their security, property and lives. Hindus in Pakistan have to live a very low profile existence, and have to put up with many insults to their honour and dignity, with no legal safeguards. They authorities in the country rarely intervene to help Hindus, and often make matters worse. There are regular reports of kidnapping of Hindu women and children, looting of Hindu property, and other forms of discrimination, persecution and dehumanisation.
Unfortunately the international media and human rights groups do not take much of an interest in all this. Together with the apathy of the general public around the world, this has meant that the Hindus of Pakistan remain a forgotten and voiceless people. The brutality that has been melted out to the Hindus in Pakistan knows few parallels in history.
Until decent minded people across the world show concern for the fate of the helpless and speak out for those without a voice, there is little hope for the Hindu men, women and children who remain in Pakistan.

  [KARACHI:          Kidnapping of Hindu girls condemned](http://www.dawn.com/2005/11/03/local13.htm)
   [Kidnap          Hindu Girl, Force Marriage to Muslim](http://www.americandaily.com/article/10362)
    By J. Grant Swank Jr. (11/25/05)
          [Some          Cases of Atrocities Against Hindu Women in Pakistan](http://www.hinduhumanrights.org/Pakistan/PakistanAtrocitiesAgainstHinduWomen.html)
          [Incidents Illustrating          the Pattern of Harassment of Hindus in Pakistan](http://www.hinduhumanrights.org/Pakistan/harrasment.htm)- Taken from a report          from December 2002
          [Extracts          relating to the human rights abuses of Pakistani Hindus from the report/book          titled: "State of Human Rights Commission of Pakistan 1999"](http://www.hinduhumanrights.org/Pakistan/Extracts.html)
          [Living in          fear:](http://www.hinduhumanrights.org/Pakistan/LivingInFear.html)The Hindu communities in Sindh are victims of the terrible law          and order situation which remains under the control oflocal influentials,          writes Imdad Soomro.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

thats the best u can come up with from the unbiased , authoritative , internationally acclaimed "hinduhumanrights.org"

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

How does it matter whether it is HinduHumanRisghts.org or Amensty International? Some serious charges have been made and if you are able to please do agree or disagree with a counter, if interested.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

What are you even talking about? I can also talk of the genoicide of Muslims being commited in India since 1947 and later. My whole family left Dehli to avoid the massacres by the ravaging Hindu & Sikh mobs.

How did Karachi's population increased from some 80,000 people in 1947 to over 8 million in the next 3-4 decades. It's the vast migration of Muslims from India(Muhajirs) to avoid atrocities commited by First Hindu/Sikh mobs and then the Governments .

Now don't even talk about the propaganda that you have been fed for your entire life i.e how secular your governments are.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

That is exactly why I excluded the pre-partition numbers which was around 25% of population. After partition and the massive exodus in both directions, the population was 15%. That has now come down to 2%. Why?

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

It matters a lot. No body subscribes to intolerance and hatered, neither me , other Pakistanis nor many sensible Indians.

But you want to lament your neighbors and then hide your face under the rock and say everything is Bright and Right in India. .

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

^ so are you denying the claims made in that article? that the population has decimated from 15 to 2 %?

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

So you are denying that Karachi's population increased from some 80,000 to more then 8 Million made up of Muslims migrating from India increasing it 100 folds in a time period of some 4 decades. And i am not even mentioning the Indian Muslims (Muhajirs) living in the rest of Pakistan.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

I have already explained that the swapping of populations between India and Pakistan at partition is already taken out to make the 25% to 15%. One side of that swap is millions of Hindus moving from Pakistan to India and millions of muslims moving from India to Pakistan (which includes Karachi).

The question and the genocide I am referring to is past that time.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

No you are wrong here completely. Migration of muslims from India to Pakistan continued almost till 1970's .It's not that 8 million muslims migrated in one day.And there was no swap of populations either etc. It was because of fear of Hindu fanatics and mobs and then your government's policies for decades towards Muslims that made them to migrate. You/we were never ever that civiliszed to swap any populations .

I guess you are those who only look at one side of the picture to keep yourself satisfied and happy.And then how come Muslim population of Indian Punjab dropped from some some 30% in 1947 to 1.5% Muslims today.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

statistics dont mean crap by themselves. to show genocide you need to show evidence of SOME mass scale killings. its just not a genocide unless theres atleast a little bit of a bloodbath.

to kill millions of people you would get some press coverage, some evidence beyond statistics.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

The Muslim population in India has gone up not down. The Hindu population in Pakistan has fallen precipitously. How do you the claim this to be a problem on both sides?

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

this is obviously a pathetic attempt at justifying hindus violence against muslims in india

its pathetic because we arnt capable of matching hindus for grotesqueness. that title is for the hindus of india alone. absolute evil. i aint limiting the title to just a small percentage. anyone who has looked into hindu riots against muslims in india has seen a glimpse of the physque at work

to be perfectly honest, i stay out of these threads because of the disgust they bring to me. the thought of a whole state's shameless people running around with machetes, raping, burning, mutalating can have that effect.

thank god pakistans people have noor, the kitemark of decency.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

Ravage- Not only this thread and its heading is wrong but he is forgeting what has happened and is happening to Muslims in India today. What happened to Muslims in Gujarat in 2002 is "genoicide".

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

StirCrasy: Use some intelligence. If population of Hindus (post-Partition) was 15 percent than it could not have reduced to 2 percent, could it? Especially when migration stopped and obviously Pakistan has not seen any genocide of Hindus. But than I have to say that this 15 percent and 2 percent figures are both right :)

The secret behind this is that after Partition, Hindus in West Pakistan was around 2 percent (Muslim population was 97 percent and amongst rest, around 2 percent were Hindus) but population of Hindus in East Pakistan was 24 percent (Muslim population was 76 percent and most of rest were Hindus). Population of East Pakistan was 20 percent more than West Pakistan. For instance, when population of Pakistan was 100 million, population of East Pakistan was 54 million and population of West Pakistan was 46 million. Hence Hindu population was:

24 percent of 54 million was around 13 million.
2 percent of 44 million was around 1 million
That means total population of Hindus in Pakistan was around 14 million or 14 perecent of Pakistan population (above article approximated it to 15 percent). Overall Muslim population of Pakistan (East and West) was around 85 percent.

After East Pakistan becoming Bangla-Desh, many Hindus from BD migrated to India and today BD population is more than 76 percent Muslim, still there is large Hindu population in BD.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

Not on eof you are able to come up with an explanation for the decimation of Pakistan's Hindu population from 15% to 2%. What is your explanation?

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

Read my above post with care and try to understand. You will get your answer.

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

Saieem - OK I reread your post. Provide a source for your numbers

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

How would you explain 30% Muslim population in Indian Punjab in 1947 dropping down to 1.5% today?

Re: The genocide of Hindus in Pakistan

Saad - I have already told you to look at it at a country level. The muslim number in India has gone up, not down.