Re: The Fallacies of Anti Hadith Arguments
I agree, and more so than the by-stander, the actual debators should not assume things about the by-stander('s way of living, methods of gaining knowledge, reading or not of these texts) without verifying it directly with the by-stander (which would take only 1 post/PM and 1 reply to that).
But by that time, the by-stander has understood the futileness of even asking out of curiosity or perhaps as a mode of gaining extra information (?) a question to the debators and as such wonders why time and again he commits the same mistake of asking a question to a debator. He even wonders whether the posting of his previous reply is still justified! Whence, having contemplated this, the by-stander decides to leave the thread.