Whats the difference between publicly speaking and singing?
Re: Tell me
*hainnnn…:aq: *
Re: Tell me
I'll rephrase it, Is speaking in public halaal and singing in public haraam??
Re: Tell me
where u getting this kinda stuff from......
what doest ur common sense say????
hmmm
**
Re: Tell me
Publicly speaking is halaal? bcoz there is no music involved & u speak for the benefit of others.
Re: Tell me
people have higher expectations of quality singing than speaking. if someone is attracting projectiles when he sings in public he shouldnt question public attitudes, maybe just invest in some lessons.
Re: Tell me
^ so publicly singing is haraam??
Mauli, i came across this reading material where the author says something like singing is against hadees
Re: Tell me
Mauli, i came across this reading material where the author says something like singing is against hadees
Mannnn ..... to tell u honestly *
*i'm the wrong person to discuss the issue of hadees cuz i dont believe in hadees.....
I would just recomment u to stick to ur common sense cuz if u'll start following *
*those ppl who live in 11110000 BC then u'll find ur self no where...
Re: Tell me
Yes! Singing is haraam! Strictly haraam. Music, musical instruments r prohibited expect for dufly.
Re: Tell me
Says who???
Re: Tell me
mashAllah so were is your updated 2006 prophet? Oh you probably dont have one, probably get wahis yourself, dont you?
Whether people agree with it or not, its proven by various hadiths that singing is not recommended especially considering the content of the songs these days.
Re: Tell me
Need exact proof, not some fabrication of word by mouth.
Mauli lol.
Re: Tell me
Look Mr. If u r an athiest or hindu then thats ur own fault and ur own life. I dont have time for arguments & this is not a religious section. In Islam music is haraam. Simple as that.
Re: Tell me
If you people dont believe in hadith, then whats the point of asking?
Re: Tell me
Re: Tell me
[quote=PhatBalongri]
mashAllah so were is your updated 2006 prophet? Oh you probably dont have one, probably get wahis yourself, dont you?
quote]
thanks for jumping to conclusion so quickly....i know where ur comming from...anyway i dont really care....anyway
Did i say i dont believe in our prophet....did i?
I was reffering it to the author of hadees .....okay
it was suppose to be sarcastic .
Re: Tell me
R u a muslim? If yes! then u probably must have gone to some madrassahs or have studied hadees at home. A muslim should be aware of these things bcoz these r one of the first lessons taught.
Re: Tell me
[quote=PhatBalongri] mashAllah so were is your updated 2006 prophet? Oh you probably dont have one, probably get wahis yourself, dont you? quote]
thanks for jumping to conclusion so quickly....i know where ur comming from...anyway i dont really care....anyway Did i say i dont believe in our prophet....did i? I was reffering it to the author of hadees .....okay it was suppose to be sarcastic .
forgiven :p
just kidding
Re: Tell me
I'm not trying to argue with anybody.....
if u say music is haram ...i wanna know ur source..
i wanna know who said that.....
i know islam is a religion which give authentic explainition to its claims....
so my query is where u coming from with this statement.
Re: Tell me
R u contridicting ur own self...... read ur post....