Demographic situation of Kashmir are similar to that of Undivided India. In undivided India, Hindus were in majority and muslims were in minority. In Kashmir, kashmiri muslims are in majority and Kashmir pandits are in minority.
When India got its independence, minority muslims got their homelands and were given and choice to go to their new homeland or stay in India. On the similar lines, if Kashmir attains independence, Kashmir will get divided on the religious lines. Just like muslims in India got their homeland, similarly kashmiri pandits will get their homeland in Kashmir, which they call Panun Kashmir (Our Kashmir).
Kashmiri muslims leadership APHC All Party Hurriyat Conference, is keeping mum on this issue. They don’t have the guts to convey this message to the local muslim population of Kashmir, a part of Kashmir will become Panun Kashmir. That is the reason, muslims leaders like Geelani and Yaseen malik are ready to invite Kashmir pandit brothers to kashmir but on the condition that kashmiri pandits will have to support the muslim Tehreek. Kashmiri Pandits have no reason to support the Tehreek of the muslims.
Its high time local muslims of kashmir should know this fact. Their leadership is doing a big blunder by not conveying them this message. Any state that has achieved independence in modern times has undergone division. Examples, India-pakistan was created, Pakistan-Bangladesh was created, Czechoslovakia- Czech and Slovakis etc. etc.
The people who will question or condemn the creation of Panun Kashmir will be indirectly condemning the creation of Pakistan because pakistan was created on similar ground, a homeland for muslims of India
That's a longstanding hypocrisy of muslims of the valley. And it is one reason why people get scared of changing demographics towards muslim population at many places in world. Kashmir will be divided if ever a solution emerges. Pandits have been in exile for 20+ years strange humanity goes for a toss on question of religion. Yaseen Malik is a butcher of kashmiri hindus...Pandits will go back to valley soon and he can only lick his wounds..
Demographic situation of Kashmir are similar to that of Undivided India. In undivided India, Hindus were in majority and muslims were in minority. In Kashmir, kashmiri muslims are in majority and Kashmir pandits are in minority.
When India got its independence, minority muslims got their homelands and were given and choice to go to their new homeland or stay in India. On the similar lines, if Kashmir attains independence, Kashmir will get divided on the religious lines. Just like muslims in India got their homeland, similarly kashmiri pandits will get their homeland in Kashmir, which they call Panun Kashmir (Our Kashmir).
Kashmiri muslims leadership APHC All Party Hurriyat Conference, is keeping mum on this issue. They don't have the guts to convey this message to the local muslim population of Kashmir, a part of Kashmir will become Panun Kashmir. That is the reason, muslims leaders like Geelani and Yaseen malik are ready to invite Kashmir pandit brothers to kashmir but on the condition that kashmiri pandits will have to support the muslim Tehreek. Kashmiri Pandits have no reason to support the Tehreek of the muslims.
Its high time local muslims of kashmir should know this fact. Their leadership is doing a big blunder by not conveying them this message. Any state that has achieved independence in modern times has undergone division. Examples, India-pakistan was created, Pakistan-Bangladesh was created, Czechoslovakia- Czech and Slovakis etc. etc.
The people who will question or condemn the creation of Panun Kashmir will be indirectly condemning the creation of Pakistan because pakistan was created on similar ground, a homeland for muslims of India
Demographic situation of Kashmir are similar to that of Undivided India. In undivided India, Hindus were in majority and muslims were in minority. In Kashmir, kashmiri muslims are in majority and Kashmir pandits are in minority.
When India got its independence, minority muslims got their homelands and were given and choice to go to their new homeland or stay in India. On the similar lines, if Kashmir attains independence, Kashmir will get divided on the religious lines. Just like muslims in India got their homeland, similarly kashmiri pandits will get their homeland in Kashmir, which they call Panun Kashmir (Our Kashmir).
Yamaha,
There is a huge flaw in your argument. The division of India was based on the fact that certain regions in India had a Muslim majority and that they had to be contigous. So certain regions like the Lakhshadweep Islands, north east Bihar, North Malabar and west Rohilkhand, which had Muslim majorities but were not contigious were not included in Pakistan
It is a historic fact that the Kashmir valley has had a Muslim majority since the middle ages. There isnt a single district in the valley that has a Hindu majority, so where will this Panun Kashmir be created.
I have always adovocated the Dixon or Chenab formula, which would give eastern Jammu, Zanskar and Ladakh to India, on account of their non-Muslim majorities to India, while western Jammu, Kargil and the valley should go to Pakistan.
And on the ethnic cleansing point, the Jat and Rajput Muslims of eastern Jammu, were also expelled in 1947.
the whole idea of muslims can only live with muslims went out of fashion in 1971 when muslims massacred over a million muslims over whose skin is fairer. so the original poster's argument is outdated.
Yeah the Kashmiris are wrong. Not the Indians who are the worlds "largest democracy" yet can't give the Kashmiri people the simple right to self-determination. No vote for the kashmiris and its all their own damn fault. For shame!
Yeah the Kashmiris are wrong. Not the Indians who are the worlds "largest democracy" yet can't give the Kashmiri people the simple right to self-determination. No vote for the kashmiris and its all their own damn fault. For shame!
There you go again .... inspite of knowing the fact that Pakistan has to vacate all areas in jammu & kashmir before a plebiscite takes place, you blame India for it ... typical :D
Yamahas question was whether Kashmir can be divided on the basis of religion. The simple answere to that question is no, as there isn't a single district in Kashmir that has a Hindu majority.
Yamahas question was whether Kashmir can be divided on the basis of religion. The simple answere to that question is no, as there isn't a single district in Kashmir that has a Hindu majority.
This is perhaps the basic mistake that every Pakistani makes ... the dispute is not over Kashmir ..... it is over the princely state of Jammu & Kashmir and that needs to be resolved.
LMAO! Aam Banda three threads and still no answer. Prove your claim. Already discredited in three threads, but by all means go ahead with the propoganda.
Jihadis in 1948? Wow. I guess the Indian education is really into revisionist tactics
how is it revisionist? if your point is they weren't called jihadi's in 1948 and went by a different name, sure. But only the name was different.
Like whether a group calls themselves L.E.T al ABC or al BCD or al Gore, they are still the same L.E.T al sob's.
There is no point pointing this out to them ... it has been mentioned even in UN resolutions that Pakistani national had entered Kashmir (now you can all them Jehadi or Shahahi is upto you) for the purpose of fighting ... but tehy don't want o belive that ...... heads in the sand !!!!!
the whole idea of muslims can only live with muslims went out of fashion in 1971 when muslims massacred over a million muslims over whose skin is fairer. so the original poster's argument is outdated.
Well mr. history teacher
think beyond that
think before 1971
its a shame that i have to tell you this
but muslims have been fighting with each other even before 1971.
well i know some pretty fair Bengalis
are u fair mr. queer?
There is no point pointing this out to them ... it has been mentioned even in UN resolutions that Pakistani national had entered Kashmir (now you can all them Jehadi or Shahahi is upto you) for the purpose of fighting ... but tehy don't want o belive that ...... heads in the sand !!!!!
Well indian government puts not only HEAD in the sand of poor innocent kashmri's
they put the whole body in the sand
they are murderers of thousands of innocent kashmiri's
still there is no investigation into the hundreds of massgraves that are found in
Indian Occupied Kashmir.
Innocent Kashmir's killed by coward and sissy Indian army.
