Re: Taliban terrorists kidnap Indian driver (Merged)
You did not get the point from my #2 question.
Geneva convention does not bother people who have no concern of rule of law.
In all of myposts I used 'could have' and its you who confirmly said it. We would not be havijg further discussion if someone had said Yes he might have been considered a spy. Weahter he was a spy or not was not my question.
Moreover, if you already agreed or confirmed (despite that I did not ask anyone to confirm that he was a spy), then why bring Geneva question to extend the discussion unnecessarily?
There is a big difference in could have or asking for confirmation.
Turning the topic has never been my virtue and I do not have to tell you about Indians being the master at it...just search few and I mean really few of the threads and I am sure you will get the same impression.
Re: Taliban terrorists kidnap Indian driver (Merged)
[quote]
Ohh this is the same strategy u people applied in Bengladesh where ur crap army butchered millions of unarmed civilians ,raped women and small children of both Hindu and Muslm community.Atleast they had India to flee to or MGRATE to.Tell me what kind of pests and pets were there in taht country
[/quote]
Now prove to me that these civilians were not spies. They were living in a war zone you know.
.....
....
Prove to me that these people were not spies
Re: Taliban terrorists kidnap Indian driver (Merged)
Well where did the BD civilians migrate to when they could not survive the Pakistani army brutality. They fled to a neighbouring country.
In the same way, why cant the kashmiris mirgrate to Pakistan. Pakistan I think would be more than willing to accept these refugees I suppose.
Re: Taliban terrorists kidnap Indian driver (Merged)
If he is a muslim Iraqi spy…he deserves to be killed(as he naturally becomes a terrorist)…if he is an indian/US/UK spy…Geneva convention should be applied…bhaee wah…
Re: Taliban terrorists kidnap Indian driver (Merged)
Janab Goliko Sahab,
I thought I was done with this thread, but people keep on quoting me, Goliko Bhai where have you seen me applaud or condone or rejoice any death specially one that has not been given a fair trial, be it Muslim, or Iraqi or a Spy or for that matter Indian or American or British???
I even Applauded the Pakistan Government for Trying Sarabjeet Singh before Sentencing him to death, where as like I said earlier, Poor Mr Kutty was plain simple murdered.
Can you please put your money where your mouth is??
Re: Taliban terrorists kidnap Indian driver (Merged)
[quote]
Besides no one has answered could this man have been considered a spy!
[/quote]
Let me not cry myself hoarse. When you make an allegation, the onus is onto you to prove that he was a spy. From the world that you come from, it is no surpise that you are still harping on the same point.
Re: Taliban terrorists kidnap Indian driver (Merged)
Looks like the real Deedawar Bhai is Back,
Deedawar Bhai, you have been asking and asking and asking a yes or no question about Mr Kutty being a spy or not.
I have twice answered that question with a Yes answer, that yes HE WAS A SPY!!!, In return I asked you, given that he was a spy was it ok to kill him without a trial, a Yes or No question, which you have yet to answer. Can you attempt it this third time around, YES or NO??
Maybe you just read selectively, maybe if you scroll thru the thread you will see your question has already been answered, now the ball is in your court, you want to give a Yes or No answer, or you want to turn this discussion into another direction.
You not answering my question is not such a big issue for me, My issue is that why are you repeating the same question when it has been answered atleast TWICE. I seriously think you are just trying to bury away old posts, so that folks will eventually get frustrated and just walk away, which is Exactly I am going to do.
Re: Taliban terrorists kidnap Indian driver (Merged)
Read again My pervious points Ma Mooli Jee, I only conceded that point to bring Deedawar Bhai back on track, he was just going round and round.
So when He insisted on a Yes or No question,
I used the same Logic, that if given that he is a spy, should you just kill him without a trial, May be you would care to answer that question Ma Mooli Jee, Yes or No??
Re: Taliban terrorists kidnap Indian driver (Merged)
And dear Aejaz you have not read my post after your confirmatory response on your own that he WAS a spy.
Throughout all my post I said and had bold letters used for ‘COULD HAVE BEEN’ meaning, there might have been a suspicion of him being a spy which might led to his death. Again I never said he WAS a spy. I never asked anyone to CONFIRM that he was a spy.
I did say that it is quite possible that any person in war zone (justly or unjustly, right or wrong) can be considered a spy. All you indians have had to say yes it is quite possible’…that might have been the end of discussion. No need for confirmation or dragging the issue.
Someone brought the discussion about Pakistan problem and I mentioned that spy problem most definitely exist in Pakistan as well…hearing about targetted killings and completely outrageous acts like someone killing innocent people during friday prayer…!!!
BTW, let me ask anyone…why is that when a muslim dies or is victimised people do not talk about in media and everywhere how many kids that poor person might have? As opposed to…a father of two is killed in such and such incidence…
‘a father of four is kidnapped’…etc.? Someone mentioned this info about the indian guy in this thread as well.
