Re: Tahirul Qadri’s long march
Can you please tell me how you conclude that a person is lying if that person is telling something he dreamt? Is it that you have some sort of super-human or god like power to know what a person really saw in his dream?
People can dream many things and try to explain that according to their understanding and perception. So, whatever TUQ claims he saw in dream, only Allah and he knows the best. If his dream bothers someone then that could not be TUQ problem but problem of those who get bothered.
As for seeing Prophet (SAW) in dream, we are told that no one can come in dream portraying as Prophet (SAW). But then, we also know of Mullah Umar’s dream on ‘Khandhar not falling to NA and Americans’ still that man ran away from Kandhar on motor cycle to save his life (according to news of that time) when it was certain that Khandhar is going to fall. Worse is that, many others so-called respectable religious personalities claimed similar to happen (Khandhar not falling to allies) … still no one criticised Mullah Umar’s dream but criticism was on his behaviour after the dream (his running away against his claimed dream ). Fact is that, we cannot say that their (Umar and others) dreams were untrue or that they did not see dream, rather we can only say or assume that their imagination was dictating their dream or they were hallucinating (same is true about TUQ dream) … but obviously, their claims cannot be called ‘lie’.
As for TUQ claims that he started his march with 100 thousand people, than that also is a claim according to TUQ’s perception (or according to whatever people around TUQ told him). Your claim is according to your perception. Fact is that you did not count them nor any media men counted them neither I believe TUQ counted them and all claims are on basis of perception. Figures are different according to who perceived the figure. Who knows what number of people TUQ or people around him were seeing in their perception others were or were not seeing (perceiving).
It is just like Jiyalas see that BB was very respectable and honoured personality worldwide and Zardari thinks that BB was icon of democracy and there is democracy all over the world because of BB and her sacrifices. But for most people who are aware of world media perception of BB believe that BB was always looked throughout world as corrupt and opportunist thug, and that no one in their right mind (other than thugs like her in Pakistani politics) believe that she was a politicians or had any high stature. Same is the perception of Zardari, Nawaz and most Pakistani politicians all around the world.
[Pakistani thugs in politics can be considered as politicians only if politician means thugs fooling people effectively that they want to serve people and not make them fool].
Well, jiyalas think that BB passed them as slaves (PPP party and workers) to Zardari in her will, and thus Zardari inherited them, so now most are loyal servant of Zardari as they were of BB regardless of what she was. For non Jiyals it is a joke of the century that Zardari played by producing BB ‘will (waseeyet)’ to hoodwink innocent PPP Jiyala slave workers, jiyala slave leaders, and Pakistani zombie voters. … hmmm well, Jiyalas bought Zardari deception too.
So, if you want to call someone liar than be logical in that too, else you would be earning sin without any gain. Let me explain you what is lie:
Lie: saying or claiming something as if what you are saying or claiming is true … even though you sincerely believe that whatever you are saying or claiming is not true. …
Not lie: It is not a lie if you promise something (sincerely with intention to fulfil your promise at time of promise) and still could not fulfil that promise (for whatever reason) … Thus lie in promise is only know to person promising or Allah, so no one (in general) can say that one was lying when one was promising. … Similarly, it is not lie if you dreamt or perceived you dreamt something (however absurd) and said that to others … because here only you and God knows what you really saw in dream and what you perceived.