Thousands protested and reiterated that the incident didn’t took place in swat and that the video is a fake made to sabotage the peace accord between Govt and Swaties. ( Source BBC)
?BBC Urdu? - ??? - ??? ??? ??? ?? ??? ???](سوات میں وڈیو کے خلاف مظاہرہ - BBC News اردو)
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
We did have a similar protest against "false" accusation/defamation of Faridkot :D
We did have a similar protest agains "false" accusation/defamation of a village where a guy named "Kasab" was alleged to have lived :D
Exclude me from the " WE" ...May be you protested but not " ME"
I didn't talk in terms of ME and We....... , read the BBC link **
**!......
Don't like it then..blame the BBC go and sue them:):) or perhaps......a better way for you would be " Declare BBC supporter of taliban) hahaha
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
Someone needs a lesson in English, claiming to be a graduate.
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
^^ Bitter Reality
are you from Swat or do you know the language can u confirm that the language in video is commonly spoken in Swat?
^^ Bitter Reality
are you from Swat or do you know the language can u confirm that the language in video is commonly spoken in Swat?
The issue is not my language skills , I have presented a BBC link as proof of my argument.
I have family freinds in Swat and they also confirmed that the accent of Pashto they spoke in the video is not local to Swat. The people in swat are worried that the video is an attempt to sabotage the peace accord between govt and swaties.
Also, the time stamp of video shows its a two month old video , nevertheless the video has got lots of attention...reminds me of a fake beheading video on youtube made by some prankster.
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
^ the same family friends who told you about army declaring curfew and burning/destroying girls schools? yeah, some credibility you have there.
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
^^ Well i am not judging anything here, i have posted this article in this thread http://www.paklinks.com/gs/pakistan-affairs/316956-malakand-commissioner-confirmed-swat-girl-flogging-video-fake-his-report.html
and the writer of the article is saying that the it is not swati language.. now you said the same thing can you please tell me which language/accent it is?
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
whats so fake about this video?
As I said I am not a linguistic expert. I posted what BBC reported and what the people of that area are saying about this fake video.
Thanks
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
What the hell does it matter if it's real or fake?? The fact of the matter remains that things like this still happen there!!! It's time we start focusing on the real issue of how to get these idiots to stop or get them out of the country instead of arguing over the validity of this video.
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
u Mean if the video is fake still we should prosecute them???
which system in this world allows to prosecute a person ( good or bad) for the crime he have not committed???
u Mean if the video is fake still we should prosecute them???
which system in this world allows to prosecute a person ( good or bad) for the crime he have not committed???
Again how is this video fake?
Were they hired actors?
Were they doing a stage show?
Were they street performers?
Man get a grip. Stop deflecting blame and be a Man and own up to the fact that these people are barbarians are still living 2,000 years in the past and are the biggest threat to Pakistan
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
Even if this video is fake, they admitted flogging of another woman who was going out with her father in law... were they lying about that too?
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
There is NOTHING fake about this video.....I watched it only once but it had made my blood boiled and her crying still echoing in my ears. What about the big banners hanging on the streets of Swat "No Women allowed" . Are you kiddign me?? WHo the hell are these jahils telling women not to go to bazaaars.....something needs to be done immediately to kick these people out of the country. They don't deserve to stay in Pak. It is the government (Zardari) who himself is the biggest wadera who would never do anything to take immediate action. So people need to stand up and help themselves.
u Mean if the video is fake still we should prosecute them???
which system in this world allows to prosecute a person ( good or bad) for the crime he have not committed???
please tell me where in my post i said that the taliban should be prosecuted based on that video?? i dont know the validity of that video and quite frankly dont care. the taliban should not be prosecuted, they should be gathered and either nuked in some far off island or they should all be bunched together in a gas chamber till they all die. and honestly even these two options would make us all seem like the nice guys, they deserve the most awful and excruciating punishments ever!
Again how is this video fake?
Were they hired actors?
Were they doing a stage show?
Were they street performers?
Man get a grip. Stop deflecting blame and be a Man and own up to the fact that these people are barbarians are still living 2,000 years in the past and are the biggest threat to Pakistan
U mean to say that hiring such people, and getting this video maked is something impossible and no one can think about it????
In that case, what prove it is that the video is from Swat as nothing in the video says about it and the language/accent used is not Swati... so i have some point when i say that the video is not swati.. but u are just saying it because you said so...
what an argument
please tell me where in my post i said that the taliban should be prosecuted based on that video?? i dont know the validity of that video and quite frankly dont care. the taliban should not be prosecuted, they should be gathered and either nuked in some far off island or they should all be bunched together in a gas chamber till they all die. and honestly even these two options would make us all seem like the nice guys, they deserve the most awful and excruciating punishments ever!
when you say that it doesn't matter the video is real or fake...
anyway i am not supporter of Taliban, infact i consider them traitors, these traitors should be killed their wealth and land should be taken over by the govt. their relatives should be thrown out of country... ( the minimum punishment for them)
please tell me where in my post i said that the taliban should be prosecuted based on that video?? i dont know the validity of that video and quite frankly dont care. the taliban should not be prosecuted, they should be gathered and either nuked in some far off island or they should all be bunched together in a gas chamber till they all die. and honestly even these two options would make us all seem like the nice guys, they deserve the most awful and excruciating punishments ever!
I do fully and entirely agree with Sumo , who cares if the video was real or fake .. they are distracting our attention to other issues when the real issue at hand is how to deal with taliban who are wrecking hell in our country.
even if the video is fake , it doesnt change the reality of the taliban ..... so we as a nation should apply max pressure on the wadeira government to take stern actions against them taliban.
Re: Swat People Protest Against the Fake Taliban Video
Can I post a video of polish engineer being beheaded? Was that fake also and was the talib snakes lying about killing him? Ghair Muslim Khan has already admitted that they illegally flogged a girl.
I doubt bitter_reality can speak a word of pushto. It's not that difficult to tell the difference between regional pushto accents.